The Archive · 1938

Judge Rebukes Plaintiff For His Expressions

A father's claim against his son arising out of a dispute over a will was dismissed by Judge P. Grant Jones in Hi M. Supreme Court yesterday. The plaintiff, Thomas Henry Artindale, claimed that the sum of $250, which, he alleged, was due to him under the terms of a maintenance clause in his mother's will, had not been paid by his son, Frederick Henry Artindale, who together with his brother was an executor of the estate.

The defendant, who was represented by Mr. K. E. Newman, admitted that the money was owing io his father, but stated that as the estate was insolvent, it had been impossible to pay the full amount of the allowance each month, which was $150. He and his-brother, however, had paid out of their own pockets the sum of $125 monthly; therefore their father was suing for the balance of $25 which should have been paid to him each month.

Plaintiff, on oath, claimed that his pressions. I will direct you when to speak.

Plaintiff then questioned his son and when told to keep quiet by the Judge on several occasions used the term "O.K.", to which His Honour replied "Where do you pick up these disgraceful expressions like OX?" "The whole things a fraud," continued plaintiff after further questioning, "You are lying and you know it" he said to his son. In conclusion, he added, "Do you see this young man going to the extent of paying a lawyer instead of paying me The case was then dismissed.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account