Observation v. Deduction.
To the Editor of the "Nowr-Cinwa Datey News"
Stn-—I must ask your pardon and that of your readers for returning to the subject of the way the common garden spider, one of the large "orb Weavers" as they ate called, constructs ils snare; but I notice in today's issue of your newspaper that Me. ES. Witkinson, in his "Stray Notes" of September 6, written at Weihaiwei, says that the' spiders of this type ai Weihaiwei all use the wind-blown method to get the first supporting strand of their snares in position. 1 is noteworthy, however, that he docs not say that he has actually observed them using this process; but that, Vike all the other' writers on the subject I have been able to consult, he assumes that they use this method because he also assumes that the method of crawling from one attachent point of the supporting strand to the other is impossible for any spider to accomplish. I also have never observed the wind-blown method being used by these large spiders, but" have actually caught stich spiders in the act of using the crawling method, which Mr. Wilkia~ son says is impossible. Also T have observed that the plane of the large snares, constricted "by such spiders more frequently than not lies at right angles to the direction of the prevailing wind in the particular areas which Ihave observed them, 'Thus Tam offering both direct and Indirect evidence in support of my contention that the garden. spider usually, if not always, gets the supporting' strand of its share in position by: the laborious method of crawling from one attachment point to another, paying out web as it goes and finally hauling in the slack and making fast at both points." Mr. "Wilkinson, Mr, Sanger and other writers on the sub-
Jeet, on the other hand, offer" ths very dubious indirect evidence that such 'a method. Is impossible ans therefore cannot be the one. used But, as I have already said, 1 have rot been able to find a single state: ment in the writings of the author! tes) and observers T have been able to consult to the effect. that thes large spiders have been seen usin the wind-blown method of getting th main strand of their snares. in posi ton.
Tf, however, Mr. Wilkinson or any|||} other competent observer will make fand publish. the statement that they have actually seen the wind-blowa method in use, then, as a. scientist seeking only the true facts, 1 shui be prepared to accept the theory as 4 proven fact, and not ti then. Even Fabre, who writes 30 delightfully on things pertaining to the lower forms of animal life, doos not say that he actually saw this method in use, although he describes in detail how the spider makes the strand which he says, is allowed to hang. with a loop at its end from one point of attachment until, waving in' the breeze, its loose end' contacts and becomes entangled in some object.
The same is the case with the Australian author,—K. C. MeKei quoted by your correspondent F. Roberts in the August 30 issue of your newspaper. T have looked up the passage quoted from his book "Spider Wonders of Australia," an' again note that he does not spectilcally' state that the wind-blown. niethod has been observed. He mere-assumes that It. is the one used because any other is seemingly impossible and proceeds to describe it. Incidentally, he and Fabre do not agree as to how the strand that Is, alleged to be watted on the breeze fructed, This in Itself is. highly lus-and casts serious doubt upon the accuracy of one, or other, oF both of these writers.
My, Wilkinson further say's tha Weihaiwei spiders do not work exact spiral - commencing from contre in putting in the cross-strands of their snares, but run back and forth to do original task, He puts this down to wind and atmospheric "conditions altering the strength of the strands 50 that they need bracing, as it were. To me what he has observed sounds much more like a. spider repairing its old web after the wear and break= ges of a nights's than the! construction of a br snare, T have often observed brand-shew snares and noted with wonder the perfection of the spiral "cross webbing. On the other nand 1 have also frequently noted snares in which the spiral strand is interrupted. In places and" the pattern. irregular, obviously the result of Directly' after a spider and. disposed of some starts to repair the damage done to its snare by the insect's steugiles, fand these repairs must necessarily' have the appearance of patchwork, s0 that the original perfection of "the snare's pattern Is lost Also T- have frequently watched from start to finish these large spiders building new snares, and have always marvelled atthe steady and methodical way they yo about the Business and the regularity of the Anished work. Perhaps if Mr. Wil-Kinson will observe his spiders more closely he will discover' that even
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.