To the Editor of the "Nomni-Cunea Daruy New Sur,—Onrwooox Catuotte can hardly be serious in his claim that the JOrthodox Church is the real Catholic IChureh since it is common knowledge that the Patriarch at Constantinople Jond his followers broke away. from the present Roman Catholic Church lin 1054 for political reasons. apologized snd were readmitted into the fold 1438, and were. finally excom-Jmunicated by Pope Leo 1X in 1504.
Haman Catholics however recognize the apastolle descent of the Orthodox. (Catholic Church and admit that its nels are properly ordained but not validly able to exercise their priestly functions on account of the excommunication mentioned above.
'When I wrote my first letter I made statement that the majority' [Christians were Roman Catholics be-Jeause T had forgotten. the fact that this ban of excommunication was still in existence, since many Ca-holies are in the habit of overlooking the fact that differences do exist between the two churches; because of the genuine apostolic descent of the priests of the Greek church. The fol-Towing figures taken from Whitakers JAlmanae "for 1997, and quoted in ironnd mit tions, will show however that my' statement was not far out even when the antagonism to the Pope on the part of the Orthodox [Church is taken into consideration:
Roman catholic, Protestant "Churches Tot and, in view of the recent increases: in Catholic numbers, my statement was likely correct.
As regards the question of expediency raised by Veetras. Viserr, 1 might remind him that the Church of England owes its inception to that outstanding defender of the Faith, King Henry VIII of England, who for some forty years was a staunch Catholic, acknowledging. the supremacy of the Roman Pontiff, who renounced his allegiance because the Holy Father refused to ive religious sanction to his amorous desires. Likewise another apostate, Martin Luther, who was responsible for so much of the dissension which has reigned amongst Christians since his day, was in his early days a most ardent Roma Catholic, and he also broke away from the true church because he wished to marry a woman who was 8 professed. nun.
T am not a student of Canon Law 0 1 will not attempt to argue about but T might remark that it would not surprise me to hear that there were still laws on the Statute Book in England condemning one to be hanged, drawn and" quartered for sheep stealing, or some such heinous crime as playing marbles on the Sabbath. Incidentally it ix but a very few years ago that Catho-lies in England were finally relieved from the disabilities attaching to the old Penal Laws.
Finally, my other statement might perhaps have been better worded had T said "The Roman Catholic Church is the only Church that has dared, with any rightful Justification, to claim to be the universal church, ie. The Catholic) Church.
Shanghai, Sept. 29.
The Varying Sects To the Editor of the "Nosr-Curwa Datty News"
'Sm—Since the debate between Vamiras ano Venax has widened out by the entree ex scene of Ontio00x 'Caruotic, and always at the expense fof the Roman Pontiff, kindly allow a Catholic who is not' "Orthodox" to return to the charge, not indeed against my separated brethren but against error only.
First of all, I notice with satisfucton that Onztiopox Car#otic excludes all Protestants from the Catholic community, with the possible excep-ion—though it isn't clear just why—of the Anglicans, separated from Rome in the sixicenth century less than the Lutherans and" the Calvinists of the time. This exclusion will not be very pleasing to Ventras, Dut on one point at Toast it brings me closer to your correspondent.
Unfortunately, this latter taxes Manaea with an undeserving reproach. Manna did not say that the "Latins" were the only ones who have ventured to claim for their Church the litle of Catholic; the Church of Rome is not wholly Latin. In addition te the 250 million members of the Latin Rite whom the Church embraces in her fold" in Europe and South America, it includes "in North America, Africa, Asia, Oceania and the Near East 60 million faithful who wre not of the Latin Rite; and of this number, 8 million Orientals who pray in their own rite and their own Tanguage, while at the same time pro: fessing the Faith of Rome. But per hhaps "this is merely a quarrel words, Much more serious, however, is this fact: Onruopox Carwoute excludes the Church of Rome from Catholicism fu the score that it broke away from the Catholic patriarchates in the yeat 1054." The truth of the matter is that the Church of Constantinople eliminated itself from the unity of Christendom in breaking off relations with the Pope. Before the schism It was the Pope who, throughout the centuries was universally recognized fas the head o. the Church, and the Church "has no power whatever to exclude its own Supreme head.
On this question of the primacy of the Pope let me cite several scholarly: theologians or historians, all of whom re "Orthodox", besides mentioning "Orthodox" liturgy which i still muse.
1—Bolotov, in his History of the Ancient Church (Lektsii po Istorit Grevnei Tserkvi, 1913, Tome IT, p2 and pp.280-301)' writes that "in' the exposition of St. Leo (440-461) are found the same Roman prerogatives which were defined in the Vatican Council." Tt should be noticed in passing that Bolotov was the principle defender of the Old Catholics established in Russia and that he devoted special study to the Vatieon Council, 2—A. Pavtov, in 1807, edited an ancient document written in the time of St. Methodius (9th century), and which figured, at least up to the 12th century, in the official collection of Nomocanon Slavonicus In this source the follow-Ing can be read:
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.