The Archive · 1940

An Historic Parallel

There was a time in the Napoleonic campaigns when there was a general demand supported by Fox for the opening of negotia~ tions with Napoleon Buonaparte. It was opposed by William Pitt, the younger, in a speech which has been preserved and might with but a few changes be a suitable vehicle in which to convey a British refusal to discuss peace with the Axis Powers should such a feder result from the Brenner Pass conference. Pitt in his lengthy address, which reads nowadays so inspiringly, outlined the aggressions of Buonaparte and wound up that section of his speech as follows:—

'The interview granted exclusively to the 'North-China Daily News," by Mayor Fu: 'Siao-en on the local rice situation should give the authorities of the foreign areas of Shanghai, as' well as all residents, food for very serious' thought, for he has said quite openly what many have suspected to be the case for avery long time past. Alleging that the Shanghai Rice and Bean Merchants' Assoc tion is behind the manipulation of the rice market, Mayor Fu demands as the first essential to remedying the present state of affairs that that body should be abolished, after which he would be prepared to cooperate with the authorities in the foreign areas in order to improve the situation. Mr. Fu is to be regarded as an authority on the ques-on of the rice supply for Shanghai, for as he says himself, he was formerly' in the business, and in' addition to the experience then acquired has spent considerable money investigating the matter recently. In tion to manipulation he charges hoarding. The allegations are quite clear and definite, and the question which the foreign authorities have to answer is what they are going to do about it.

Dealing with the subject of high food prices n February last this journal wrote:—

It will be noted that the Shanghai Municipal Council is granting the lower paid of its Staff a rice allowance to meet these abnormal increases. That is all very well as far as oes, but does anyone in his sober senses believe for one moment that.the evil is to be cured by thus paying tribute to the profiteers hoarders who patently exist in Shanghai?

The months which "have passed since that question was first asked have answered it most emphatically. The appetite of the manipulators has increased with eating, and the price of rice has been pushed up to Limits almost unbelievable. What attempts have been made to prevent this have either been half-hearted, or not calculated to defeat these unscrupulous merchants who are. battening on the misfortunes of the community. The danger, if this is allowed to continue unchecked, is obvious. The patience of the poorer classes of Chinese to whom the question of the cost of rice it the all important one, marvellous as it has been, annet be expected to last if the price of ce is permitted to go much higher.

It is consequently of imperative necessity that immediate steps should be taken to check the rapacity of those Mayor Fu bluntly declares responsible for the existing state of affairs, and not only should they. be checked but steps should be taken to en= sure that the price of rice in Shanghai should more in conformity with prices prevailing the source of supply. There is much to Support the view expressed by the Mayor that the authorities could resort to drastic measures in dealing with manipulators in the rice market. "Since rice is the staple I needed by: all Chinese." he says, "the would never condemn the authorities, strict measures against pro-

And it is strict measures which necessary' if an intolerable situation is to be ended. As it has been pointed out in these columns time and again, unprecedented problems. rear unprecedented solutions, and nothing which has happened in the past should be allowed to prevent adequate action now being taken, Mayor Fu offers his cooperation on cer= tain conditions.—the abolition of the Shanghai Tice and 'Bean Merchants' Association ind the participation of his police in joint estigation with the police of the foreign reas. There appears ta be no solid reason why this could not be done. Tu other direc tions cooperation between the authorities of the foreign areas and Mayor Fu's administra "Look, then, at the fate of Switzerland, at the circumstances which led to its destruction Add this instance to the catalogue of ageres sion against all Europe, and then tell me when ther the system I have described has not been prosecuted with en unrelenting spirit, which cannot be subdued in adyers be appeased in. prosperity, which neither solemn' professions, nor the' general law of nations, nor the obligation of treaties (when ther previous to the Revolution or subsequent to it) could restrain from the subversion of every state into which either by force or fraud, their arms could penetrate. Then tell me whether the disasters of Europe are to be charged upon the provocation of this country and its allies, or on the inherent principle of the French Revolution, of which the natural result produced so much misery and carnage France, and carried desolation'and terror over so large a portion of the world."

It only requires a few changes of names in the foregoing passage to apply with complete appropriateness to Hitler and his Nazi Germany, and shows that the way of dicta tors may be measured by common denomina~ tors.

But the parallel between Napoleon and Hitler and their two systems is even clearer:

Its first fundamental principle was to. bribe the poor against the rich, by proposing 10 transfer into new hands, on the delusive notion of equality, and in breach of every prinelple' of justice, the whole properly of the country. The practical application of this Drineiple was to devote the whole of that property to indiscriminate plunder and to make it the foundation of 'a revolutionary system of finance, productive in proportion to the misery and desolation which it created. It has been accompanied by an unwearied spirit of proselytism, diffusing itself over all the nations of the earth; a spirit which can apply Itself to all circumstances and situations... fo the Catholic of Ireland, whom It was deliver from Protestant usurpation; to. the Protestant of Switzerland, whom it was to deliver from popish superstition, and to the Mussulman of Egypt whom it was to deliver from Christian "persecution.....and to the natives of Great Britain, enjoying the perfec tion of practical freedom and justly attached their constitution from the Joint result of habit, of reason and of experience.

The last and distinguishing feature is & per Ady which nothing can bind, which no tie of treaty, no sense of the principles generally received among nations. no obligation, human or divine can restrain, Thus qualified, thus farmed for destruction the genius of the French Revolution marched forth, the terror and dismay of the world.

Every nation has in its turn been the witness, many have been the victims of its left for ur to decide will compromise with such a while we have yel resources to supply the sinews of war, while the heart and spirit of the country is yet _unbroken.

It was Pitt speaking nearly one hundred and forty years ayo, using words which with the completest truth can be applied to what has happened during the last few years. Pitt refused to negotiate. He had already' spent the greater part of his political life fighting the French Revolution, and found in Napoleon the same hideous thing incarnate in Hitler at this moment. The schemes and devices of Britain's present enemy are similar to those of the French dictator so long ago. If indeed Hitler does indulge in a little more of his plaintive peace talk it may safely be believed that Mr. Churchill will reply along similar lines. "Hitler, like Napoleon, wanted war, and Britain wil as surely let him have it as it did to the man of whom Hitler is so avowed admirer and imitator.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account