The Archive · 1939

SPECIAL ARTICLES

NEUTRALITY DEBATE

By The debate on the neutrality bill has emphasized one thing above all else, and that the determination of Congressmen of ery shade of opinion that the United States must stay out of the struggle. This opinion was combined with outspoken attacks on Herr Hitler, and all he stood for, and was equally evident in speeches which gave an unfavourable version of past British history.

secondary theme which ran through speeches made on both sides of the neutrality debate was condemnation of the dictatorial form of government. This was frequently twisted to provide an additional argument for keeping out of war on the grounds that IN democratic liberties vanished once a country was placed on a war basis. One of the reasons why the Administration were able to secure a two-to-one majority in the Senate instead of the close vote which had been anticipated earlier was that Senators who started from the assumption that the repeal of the arms embargo had been requested fa first step to war were unable to sustain that opinion for very long.

The near relative to the "step towards war" argument was the "We're bound to be dragged in" argument and this also has perished by the wayside. The overwhelming majority of Congressional and presumably of public opinion Is that the United States won't be dragged in and that there is no substance to the statement that American Involvement is inevitable. One reason for this change is that the war has not followed the expected pattern, Tt has not ranged from the Pacific to the Atlantic. Japan still attacking China but has made no effort to acquire the British and Dutch East Indies and threaten the Philippines. Russi despite her treaty with Germany not hech followed by any arrangement for carving up the Orient and ousting the Western powers. Italy too is neutral and the Mediterranean a peaceful inland sea. There have been no mass air-raids, no clash of large armies. The American public has begun to believe that the Allied Governments have the situation in hand. The argument that the United States should not permit France and Britain, her frst line of defence, to be defeated is no longer heard because the first line of defence does not appear to be threatened. At first the strange' course the war was taking was a source of bewilderment, but now it is better understood and and generally held wise. 'The slow inexor= fable pressure of the blockade is felt to be the AMlies' best weapon. It Is least wasteful of manpower and least destructive of the internal economy of either the blockading oF th Dlockaded power.

But the overwhelming sentiment in favour of "non-intervention" in the war does not mean that the United States is held by a majority of the public to be also barred from intervention in favour of peace. Tu fact the peace interventionists are extremely powerful. Even the most extreme isolationist finds no contradiction in holding that the United States should be at any peace conference to seo that its interests are not neglected, while sti sticking to his philosophy that the United States can live as in George Washington's day unentangled and free. In discussing the possibilities of peace there is always 4 faint tendency to assume that the blame for the war lies on both sides and to ignore the pre-war period in which France and Britain made every effort to avoid it, even 10 the extent of being roundly condemned in the United States for such a stand. "It eventually, why not now?" say the peace Frederick Libby, head of one of the numas fous peace lobbies, "The National Council for Prevention of War, stated recently, "Present obstacles to peace now are not even comparable with those that will confront a settlement after three bitter years....A-peace that promises well-being to all the peoples of Europe will require no guarantees from anybody. The peoples involved can be depended upon to support it, for they long for butter instead of cannon." Senator Elbert Thomas of Utah expressed similar views. The chances of a yood peace, he insisted, "depend upon the number of neutral states the world at the time the peace is made, because it is only through the forced opinion of the neutral will of the world that peace treaties can be tempered.... Under almost any circumstances the sooner peace is started the better." All these advocates of peace now skip the important point of Poland and Czechoslovakia. They obviously do not want to say that the world should be based on the theory of might makes right, because. that would hardly be a pacifist doctrine. At the same'time they do not want to admit that war was inevitable and that a peaceful settle= ment of the dispute with Herr Hitler had been tried and had failed. All they can do therefore is make a series of assumptions very few of which bear examination, Even Herr Hitler is painted is a peace lover an effort to prove the point that war

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account