The Archive · 1940

Private Eckford

There is a great deal to be said for the case put forward by a writer to the correspondence columns today in favour of making an appeal for a reprieve for Private Eckford now under sentence of death for the murder of a comrade. The man has had a fair trial, and everything that could be done for him in conformity with the law has been done. It now rests with the executive as to whether the man shall pay the final penalty for his crime. In considering that question factors have to be borne in mind which could not be considered in the course of a trial They could not even be mentioned, but now that the case is removed from the Courts they may be dealt with. Of the fact that Eckford has broken the law and placed himself in danger of death there cannot be the slightest doubt, but circumstances under which he committed his crime may with justice be considered. It has to be remembered that the various forces stationed in Shanghai have been living under conditions incomparable with what they would ordinarily expect. They have been carrying out arduous duties and subjected to temptations from which they would normally be immune, and it may very well be that this completely senseless murder may find some explanation in the undue strain which has been placed upon the men in circumstances so strange. That at least is a point for the consideration of the authorities who must ultimately decide what shall happen to the condemned man. It is understood that the papers in the case have already been sent to Chungking, so that if action is to be taken it will have to be taken quickly. In any event it does seem desirable that if there are any arguments which could be put forward in favour of the prisoner, they should be prepared as quickly as possible, and that if there are reasons why the unstrained quality of mercy should be exercised they should be placed before the appropriate authorities while there is still time.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account