Over the Spring Holidays, Admiral Mit sumasa Yonai, Japanese Navy Minister, had something to say before the House of Peers fon the subject of the closing of the Yangtze to the shipping of third party neutrals. The statement which he made in reply to inter pellation's does not differ greatly from declarations which have been made by other Japanese statesmen, though he manages to make admissions which sound somewhat strangely in view of the facts as they are] known in China. The Navy Minister is, of course, dependent upon reports which he receives from officials in this country, and it is charitable to assume that at the' most he has been misinformed. Admiral Yonai admits that "foreign Powers enjoy the right} of navigation on the Yangtze River," pointing out however, that it is not an international river as defined by international law. From this he argues that Japan being in fact at war with the Chiang Kai-shek regime, and the Yangtze forming a strategic artery, if strate~ gle necessity dictates Japan should not hesitate to close the river. The fact is, of course, that the Chinese closed it; the Japanese had to open it as they forced their way inland, this being necessary as the best means fof transporting supplies for the armies! penetrating deeper and deeper into the in terior, Had the matter rested solely on that! footing there would have been little ground of complaint, so long as the river had been opened as soon as it was militarily feasible' to do so, and Japan had thus given practical recognition to the rights of the other Powers which Admiral Yonai frankly admits do exist. But that does not end it. The "North-China Daily News" some months ago revealed with considerable detail the fact) that Japanese shipping was trading up the Yangtze, carrying not only war material, as was at first alleged, but doing a very substantial import and export trade which by. no stretch of imagination could be described a5 having military characteristics. It was claimed that the river was so dangerous, because of mines, ete, laid by the Chinese, that these instruments of destruction would have. to be removed before other foreign shipping} could use the waterway.
There was also the legend that such shipping ran the risk of being fired upon by the] Chinese, and when foreign gunboats were escorted down the river from Hankow recently a theatrical display of firing was given fo indicate dangers from the shore, which completely failed to impress foreign observers on the spot. The whole display was puerile one, canying no conviction, but! rather confirming the opinion already formed that the alleged dangers were more fancied than real. The gravamen of the complaint of third party neutrals was not merely that the Yangtze was being kept closed to them, but that they were in fact! being discriminated against by the Japanese! who had opened the river to their own commercial craft to the exclusion of all others, Admiral Yonai agrees that the! earlier the river is opened the more benefits will the Chinese receive, but he adds that] "Japan's purpose would be defeated if the Yangtze were opened for the sake of the] Chinese people and utilized by the Chiang) Kai-shek regime." How a river commanded at the mouth, and along the banks to at, least as far as Hankow by Japanese forces could be utilized in such a manner passeth all understanding. It simply could not be! done, and that must be as apparent to the] Admiral as it is to anyone acquainted with the present position. He is on equally unsafe ground when he seeks to suggest that] the reopening of the Yangtze would place Japan under a handicap, from which she has power enough to recover. The suggestion that such a procedure would create any such handicap is fatuous in the extreme. He is} standing on a veritable quicksand when he [goes on to say.
"I harbour no misgivings regarding the opening of the Yangtze itself. 1 firmly beeve that there is not a single Japanese who has such a mean idea as to attempt to reap profits from the Japanese military operations: on the Yangtze."
If the Admiral really thinks that, he is either] completely misinformed, or he' is refusing! to face the facts, which are that Japanese] commercial representatives have followed the Japanese armies up the Yangtze Valley and are seeking with the greatest possible] haste to establish themselves in what should be an exclusively strong position before the] Yangtze is again opened to all.
If that is not secking to wrest profits from Japanese military operations along the great river, it would be interesting to know what the Minister of Navy really thinks it is. The time worn excuse of "military necessity" cannot and does not cover up the fact that the Japanese officials in China are permitting their own nationals to carry on business in the occupied areas to the exclusion of everyone else, and the deduction to be drawn from all' the facts is that the reopening will not be permitted until the Japanese are rea~ sonably certain that they have established for themselves a trading position which they conceive to be invulnerable. He confesses inability to state when the waterway will again be open to all; indeed he expresses the pious hope that this will be done as early
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.