The Archive · 1939

A Strange Accident

Feb. 23.

The Japanese military officials may have some very good reason for bombing Shumchun, the small town in Kwanglung, just beyond the borders of the leased territory] of Hongkong, but it is a little difficult to understand why, so long after the capture P of Canton, it should have become necessary. They have had more than enough time to pacify the area, and the only explanation seems to be that the activity of guerillas! behind their lines called for this drastic action. Whether that is the case or not, there can be little doubt that they will have! to do a lot of explaining satisfactorily to} account for the dropping of bombs within British territory as a result of which some! eleven people have been killed and a number injured. It is reported by Domei that, the British officials take a serious view of the bombing and the machine-gun attack on the train which they are stated to contend were deliberate. A glance at the map shows it is indeed diMeult to come to any other conclusion, unless the Japanese are pre~ pared to admit that the men in charge of the aeroplanes which trespassed over British territory were under the control of incompetent aviators quite unable to read a map and compare it with the land over which: they were flying. A glance at any fairly} detailed map of that part will show that Shumchun is at one point about half a mile! from the border. That is the smallest! distance between the two, while the distance between the small town and the! bridge which carried the Canton-Kowloon Railway over the boundary, the Shumehun River, is nearer one mile and a half. The) station of Lukhu is a short distance within! the boundary on the British side, while the] stretch of railway between that station and Fanling leaves room for the conclusion that the train which was enfiladed was anything) from half a mile to 2 mile and a half south of the boundary. The bombing of Shumchun was carried out by nine aeroplanes! two of which detached themselves from the! main flight and dropped bombs on. the British owned bridge across the dividing} stream, and near the train which was also well within British territory.

The passengers in the bombed train sought] to fice into the fields when, it is reported, onc} of the aeroplanes swooped down and machine-gunned them. The distance of the spots where these things occurred from the ay parent real objective is one of the reasons for believing that this latest outrage} cannot be classified as accidental. If it is later found to have been so, then it wilh bbe impossible to escape the conclusion that} either ignorance or carelessness on the part of the Japanese fliers was the greatest contributing factor to this lamentable affair. The British staff officer who lodged a protest with Mr. Ichiro Ohta is reported to have] reminded the Japanese Consul-General of the undertaking given by the Japanese command to inform the British authorities when they contemplated launching action near the! border, and of the British assurance that) trains run on the British portion of the Canton-Kowloon Railway would not be allowed] to cross the boundary, but would stop at Lukbu within British' territory. There is! nothing to suggest that the Brilish assurance! was in any way departed from, though it is) suggested that the Japanese command did not adhere to its undertaking. Be that as} it may the fact still remains that at spots at least a mile and a half away from their! alleged objective of Shumchun Japanese aviators were borabing British territory and machine-gunning persons under British protection with the result that eleven people lost their lives. They are also said to have) launched bombs on the Kowloon-Cunton highway within the British lines and to have bombed an adjacent blockhouse. People who see in this latest incident something parallel with the sinking of the USS. Panay, and the bombing of the British river gunboats on the Yangtze after the fall of Nanking are not in the circumstances likely to be blamed, After all the Shumchun over which the bridge aimed at passes,

which every Japanese aviator should have known he ought not to fly.

It is for these reasons that it is believed that the theory of accident will fail to hold water. There is no reason to believe that the Japanese aeroplanes could not have carried out their operations against Shumchun without even passing over the very. fringe of British territory, which in itself would have been a breach' of good faith, but when points well within that area are sub-Jected to attack there is little indeed to be said for the perpetrators. It is to be hoped that the British Government will, in addition to local protests, have made by now emphatic representations to the Japanese Government. Whether anything will event-ware, other than another of those glib apologies from the making of which the Tokyo government has hada refreshing rest for Some months, remains to be seen. It is now reported that initial Japanese reports confirm the bombing of British territory 50 that there can now be no doubt as to the substantial truth of the accounts which were made earlier of the occurrence, Ad~ mission must be made, however, that in recent months the Japanese armed forces have succeeded in avoiding being embroiled with those of third party neutrals, and it is possible that this latest incident is nothing but the result of exuberant enthusiasm on the part of some flying officers who for their conduct most certainly deserve to be punish ed. If that were done, and compensation to the dependents of those who have unhappily been killed, an_ expression of re~ gret from the Japanese Government should be all that is necessary to close this unhappy Incident, with, of course, an assurance, for what it'may be worth, that everything' will be done in the future to prevent a repetition, That should not really be dim cult to give and to perform, for the Japanese troops should have no difficulty in main= taining law and order in a_ comparatively small area abutting the British boundaries, a matter which presents no serious problems.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account