May 6.
The statement issued by the Municipal Council on the subject of the proposal to hold a lottery for the purpose of raising funds for educational and social services, which are now definite and increasing charges upon the revenue of the International Settle ment, dismisses the whole matter in what may be termed the usual off-hand manner. The impression created is that the whole question has been discussed somewhat per~ funetorily, and upon the customary assumption that the proposal, being something in the nature of an innovation, cannot be acceptable. When the suggestion was first made it was argued that the whole question should be thoroughly investigated. This does not appear to have been done, the whole research, judging from the Council's statement having been devoted to discovering reasons why such a scheme could not be adopted. The predominating reason for the ejection is apparently one of principle. Had the Council's statement been left there it might have been wiser, but when it goes fon to declare the Council's policy as one prohibiting most forms of public gambling in the International Settlement, it can only: bbe accepted -with a very cynical smile, - It is fully realized that ordinarily there is a vast difference between public and clandestine gambling, but when the latter is carried on so openly that it is a matter of common knowledge, that difference seems to disappear, and whether the Council's policy is directed against most forms of public gambling or not, the fact is that there is so much of this sort of thing going on, that invocation of the alleged policy appears more in the light of an excuse for going no further in the enquiry as to the feasibility, rather than a real and overwhelming adherence to principle, The more realistic view of the esthetical consideration which the Council refers to would be that if such large sums of money are changing hands daily in the clandestine-public gambling, the Council would do well to seek to control it, and direct the money into channels where it would do far more good than in the banking accounts of the exploiters of this far flung racket.
Little more need be said upon this particular aspect of the Council's statesmen than that when other cities have adopted the same means of raising money, when the highly Successful Australian state lotteries run for years on end, this adoption of an "'tolier~ than-thou" attitude, does, in view of local circumstances, appear in a most singular ight. The second point raised by the Council is that upon legal grounds, and particularly because of the legal liabilities of the various members of the Council, any such scheme would be impracticable. That, of matters stand, there is some ground for the argument cannot be disputed, but the question does arise, and it needs to be put, as to whether the Council has enquired Into the possibility of remedying that state of affairs, Has, for example, any investigation been made as to the possibility of securing some legal relief for members of Council likely otherwise to get into trouble with - their respective courts? If it has not, then the whole question has been disposed of in a manner to which Shanghai is becoming far too much accustomed. Again appeal is made fo the law of China making the issuance of lottery tickets generally illegal unless prior permtigsion for such a lottery has been obtained from the Chinese Government. Again the question must be asked as to whether any attempt has been made to ascertain the probability of the Chinese Government giving its permission in the light of the praiseworthy objects which such a lottery would serve. If such an inquiry has not been made then the question of the feasibility of such a scheme as has been proposed has not been fully delved into, and the statement of the Council cannot, therefore, be regarded as a informed judgment on the matter, but merely an ex parte declaration and a not particularly convincing one at that. On- the face of it it would seem that were such permission granted, the legal position of the foreign councitlers, doing something which was then in accord with Chinese law, would be all the easier of modification. ird point raised by the Council was one. Here two views appeared to prevail.
They are on the one hand that such a lottery as that proposed would not bring in the financial benefits some people believe; on the other it is held, however little a municipal lottery would augment the Council's income, such increase is badly needed in order to meet the much desired extension of the Council's social services. would be interesting to know upon what grounds the first conclusion has been reached, what enquiries have been made, and what experts consulted. the view that there are other means open to the Council to obfain the money required as for example the Voluntary Entertainment Tax, there can be no agreement. That the Voluntary Enter~ tainment Tax has done well is admitted, but if it is thought that other and similar levies might serve to fill the Council's requirements its members should immediately discard it. As the period of inflation through which Shanghai is passing at the moment lengthens, the application of the law of diminishing returns is becoming increasingly apparent. 'The opinion is strongly held that there is very little opportunity of raising further funds by voluntary means, and the possibility' of any further increase in the rates is to be gravely doubted. It has to be remembered that the Council's educational and social services require millions of dollars annually, not hundreds of thousands, and it may be taken for granted that no voluntary levy is likely to bring in the large sums
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.