The Archive · 1940

The Next Premier

With the refusal of the Liberal, and Labour Opposition to participate in a reconstituted Cabinet under Mr. Neville Chamberlain, as Prime Minister, the probability of his resigning from office is considerably increased. Indeed the formation of the Conservatives, who actually voted against him in the House of Commons in the division on Wednesday, into a separate group under the leadership of Mr. L. S. Amery suggests that these particular dissidents will no longer be wholly responsive to the Government Whip, and that they contemplate taking a definite line of action against Mr. Chamberlain, while the fact that some fifty or sixty other men, who would normally support the Government, abstained from voting, indicates a very considerable weakening of the Prime Minister's position, which, while it may not be permanent, nevertheless might cause Mr. Chamberlain very considerable embarrassment in the future should he still decide to carry on. The question then arises as to which of the various candidates for the Prime Ministership would be most likely to be able to form a coalition government embracing all parties in Yhe House of Commons, so broadly based as to be fully representative of all divisions of political thought, and able to command their loyalty. The names put forward up to the present have been those of Lord Halifax, Mr. Lloyd George, and Mr. Winston Churchill. A great deal, as to which man will eventually form a Cabinet should Mr. Chamberlain resign, will depend upon the decision of the Labour Party as to with whom they would be prepared to permit their representatives to work. That decision was to have been taken yesterday, and while it would not settle the whole question of the succession to the leadership of the Government, it may have a profound effect upon the ultimate choice. In no sense are the Labour Party in the saddle as used to be the case of the Irish members on occasions at the beginning of the century, but the desirability of securing a Government representative of the whole nation makes it necessary that their decision as to the man with whom they are prepared to work, should have more than usual importance.

The very great personal antagonism to Mr. Chamberlain, Sir John Simon and Sir Samuel Hoare makes it unlikely that they will be retained in whatever new Cabinet may be formed, though there is a suggestion that room might be found for Mr. Chamberlain, who might still be able to render effective service in his old office of Chancellor of the Exchequer. With regard to the three possible successors to Mr. Chamberlain it has already been pointed out that one factor operating against Lord Halifax is that he would have to conduct the business of Government from the House of Lords, and would not be able to maintain that close personal contact with the House of Commons which in times such as these is so eminently desirable. A great deal of reference back from his deputy in the Commons to himself would tend to obstruct the swift efficient movement of the Parliamentary machine. Apart from that Lord Halifax is a man of undoubted ability, and one likely to command the support of public opinion throughout the country. In the Foreign Office he has quite clearly displayed those qualities which inspire confidence, and, his personality being what it is, he should have no difficulty in bringing together the representatives of the various parties, and welding them into a harmonious whole. Mr. Lloyd George has suddenly sprung into the limelight in a manner only to be expected of a man with such mercurial characteristics. There has been a steadily growing opinion that he alone was the best man to become Minister for Agriculture, but that was as far as it went. It is only within the last two or three days that the possibility of his return to the Premiership has been canvassed. About his general acceptability in the principal cabinet role there must be widely differing opinions. There is his great age to be taken into consideration, and the fact that by his actions since the last war he has done much to modify the high esteem in which he was then held, while his speech in the course of the recent debate does nothing to allay the impression that he might after all not be the most suitable man to lead the nation in this war which is proving to be, and will continue to do so, so greatly different from the last one.

There then remains Mr. Winston Churchill.

Of the three he probably stand: the best chance of succeeding Mr. Chamberlain. In the first place the manner in which after considerable reluctance Mr. Chamberlain included him in his Cabinet and subsequently gave him duties which indicated how great was his trust in his abilities, is reinforced by the fact that he has captured the imagination of the nation, as the man best suited to lead them to victory. There is also the vicious hate with which the enemy regards him, a hate which is indicative of the fear they have of him and his abilities. His record as First Lord of the Admiralty in the last war and in this stands him in excellent stead. It is true that he has made his mistakes, but who has not amongst the men most likely to be called upon to lead the nation in this struggle? They were made during the last war when his age might have been a contributing factor, but against all that there is the fact that the man is possessed of enormous energy, and firm determination, together with a willingness to take risks where the results might justify him in doing so. Mr. Churchill has been described, and rightly so, as the principal asset in the balance sheet of Int. Chamberlain's Administration and he now appears to be the most logical successor to his present chief. That he may be counted upon to meet the public clamour for a more active prosecution of the war than has occurred up to the present, may be taken for granted, for he comes of a family of men of action, and may be expected to be always up and doing. That his political record has earned for him the distrust of the leaders of the Conservative Party is an undeniable fact, but that is unlikely to induce them to take any line of action in any way opposing his premiership. To do so would probably do much to injure their own standing in the country. They are unlikely to make any such mistake. The probabilities are then that Mr. Winston Churchill stands nearer to the fulfilment of a long conceived ambition of becoming Prime Minister than ever before in his life, and if this proves to be the case, it will be a most popular appointment.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account