The Archive · 1940

Arbitrary Flat Rates Suggested

One variety of the manufacturer's sales tax has been developed effectively in southeast Europe (notably Austria and Hungary), where the total tax rate varied according to the number of taxable processes. This form of the tax mense legislative preparation and wi imposed in both countries only after long e: perience. The industrial products of Austria, for instance, were classified into 400 groups for the application of the tax rates. It seems that the new British tax will be rather on the lines of the manufacturer's sale taxes in Austral Canada and Turkey, with arbitrary flat rates, France and Belgium have adopted a number of special flat rate producers' taxes in certain industries, Both countries (and alsó Italy) had unfortunate experience with sales taxes on retail purchases, which proved unproductive and costly.

Many disadvantages became evident only with the change in the business cycle. Among these were the snowball effects, the raising of the prices of goods with inelastic demand, and the reduction of the consumption of goods with elastic demand. It fostered business integration by permitting multi-process concerns to pay smaller sales taxes than the single-process concerns, For the same reason independent business men became commission merchants.

In respect of inflation Continental experiences were rather favourable. Though individual prices were affected, they did not involve considerable changes in the general price level, The repressive effects of the tax on production, private spending, and the level of employment are in war-time offset by the heavy Govern ment spending, Looking at the British proposal in the light of Continental experience, one may guess that a purchase tax imposed only at one stage of manufacturing and marketing and at fairly low rates will be administratively feasible, It will not be a disappointment to the Treasury in its productivity, though, with its necessarily low rates, it will not have such importance as the sales taxes in foreign countries. On the basis of foreign experience, it is very likely that it will be difficult to get rid of this regressive and bad tax even after the war. Food is exempted, but clothing, and therefore the textile industries, will be much affected by the new tax. It will lead to price rises—even to some rise in the cost of living—but, provided the rates are low, it may not greatly increase the danger of inflation. As a measure of finance it will work in the direction of reducing consumption and will release productive resources for the Government. But it will not solve either problem, It will be a very modest and indirect contribution to both,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account