The Archive · 1940

A Wise Decision

Me, Churchill's refusal to publish air-raid casvaities in Great Britain, and the reasons he inlyes for doing so are entirely satis(actory. There is no justification whatever for publishing anything which might prove of assistance to the enemy, and such casually lists would undoubtedly be rich with information. Tt is not dificult to see why this should be the case. Publication of a list of people killed and injured in a raid upon a particular town would benefit the enemy in this manner. They are well equipped with directories and all the usual Information about localities, and the fact that Mr. and its. Blank were killed in a night air raid over a certain town would enable the fenomy to ascertain with a fair degree of ace curacy, assuming the unfortunate couple were at home as they should have been, where particular bombs dropped. It would enable the enemy command to inform the flyers that their bombs dropped some hundreds of yards east of the gasworks which wore" the Feal objective, and this method of correction would very quickly bring about an improvement in the enemy bombing. It will be noticed that the Germans are extremely reticent about the damage which the R.A. is inflicting upon German military points. Obviously they are actuated by precisely' the same reasons. Mr. Churchill's point that the whole country is on active service and nearly in the front line is rel taken. It is quite clear that the enemy when he really gets going intends to do his utmost to bomb Britain indiscriminately, and there is consequently no more reason for per-milling casualty lists tobe. published. than there would be to publish totals daily in army orders and read them out to the troops. The method of giving information to the public which the Prime Minister suggests should: completely ill the bill, without permitting the enemy to obtain information which would be Jot the greatest assistance to him.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account