The Archive · 1939

Covieeen: Mr. M. Reader Harris for

Before Judge P. Grant Jones

judgment reserved)

Shanghai, June 28.

"Direct trickery of the worst orde This case discloses a most disgrace: ful fraud on the part of the party cor parties, who have knowingly used the company for fraud." British company law here has been abused before but this is the frst time T have known it abused for fraud." These statements were made in HM. Supreme Court yesterday before Judge P, Grant Jones by Mr. Reader Harris when appearing on behalf of the First Trust Ca. of China action for damages and costs against the Shanghai Land & Finance Ca, represented by. the company's managing director, Mr. J. B. Manley.

"The case followed an appeal in 'HM. Full Court this month when, fon behalf of the plaintiff, Mr.

Reader Harris applied for an increase of damages which had been awarded by HM. Supreme Court, judgment having been entered by consent of defendant company. "This appeal was nob proceeded with as it was, discovered that Mr. Manley had not Sed the written authority to represent the company and the Appeal Judges ordered that the action should bbe treated as it was on October 16, 1936, when it was adjourned. with Tiberty to either party to re-instale four days* noti First witness to give evidence was Mr. Donald MeDonald, of the Trans-Pacific Freight Bureau of Canton Road, who stated that he was approached by a Mr. Yue, who inform-him that a INF. Chunson Sun intended to convert the Central Realty Ca. into a new company, to be styled the Shanghai Land & Finance Ca. and to apply for British registration, In order to do this Mr. Yue pointed out to witness that a British man~ ager would have to be acquired and he was invited to be manager, wit ness agreeing.

joined the company at the end of October 1924 when he discovered that Mr. Chunson Sun was the sole proprietor of the Central Realty Ca. ud the Shanghai Land & Finance o,, and that he conducted the affairs fof the company in conjunction with hig secretary, Mr. Yue, Witness was asked to sign leases soon after he Joined, one being a lease from the Central Realty Ca. to the Shanghai Land & Finance Ca, on September 15, 190.

witness, however, did not sign this! until the' end of October at the earliest, Yue stating that this was of lino Importance. When the lease was signed, he added, no money changed wands.' He was' also asked to sign several notices to tenants of the company requesting them tu future to pay their Fens to the Shanghai Land & Finance Ca, instead of the Central Realty Ca. After this wit. ness went away on holiday and returned on January 10, 1935 when he Was asked to sign a mortgage from Mr. Chunson Sun to a Mr. Okamot 'This. was done in Mr. Okamoto' office, there being present at the time Mr. Chunson Sun, Mr. P. Yue, Mr. Okamoto" and witness. money was paid over, he added.

'A day oF two later, however, he began to feel suspicious that all was not right with the Shanghai Land Finance Ca. and these suspicions were increased as the result of conversations with Mr. Yue Witness Fesigned shortly afterwards, his notice taking effect on January 31, 1938, Mr. Reginald Vane Yarrow, re~ tered partner in Duncan & Ca. of 0 Foochow Road told the Court that at the end of November, or the beginning of December 1935, Mr. Manley informed him that there was vacancy on the Board of Direc tors of the Shanghai Lapa & Finance Go. Ld. Mr. Manley pointed out that three British directors wer required for the company and that his position would be a nominal one the company was, in fact, really owned by the man Chunson Sun, 'Witness, who did not possess any shares, never attended a directors' meeting. Asked if he could explain why, ina return published by the Secretary of the company, he had been shown as holding 400 shares, witness stated that the frst time he had heard of this was when he received a copy of a letter sent by Messrs. Platt, White & Cooper to Mi. Manley on 'May 3, 1936. Witness added that he never. attended a directors' meeting and that he resigned his directorship on May 5, 1926 because he had had a very' unfortunate experience in another company of which Mr. Manley was the Tasurance Dept. of the plaintitt company, said that in 1984 Mr. Chunson Sun was the sole proprietor of the antral Realty Ca. with offices at the Sun Building, "505 Honan Road. Up to July 3, 1994 Interest had' been paid on a' mor-gage to plaintiffs. "The first default was on October 3, 1934 when the Amount of annual rent coming in from the property which had been mortgaged was about $73,000. The annual interest payable on the mortgage was $70,000.

'The principal was not paid and the plaintiffs took proceedings, a repracentative of the firm and' an official of the Chinese Court being sent {0 serve notices of provisional attachments on the tenants of the property. Here they found that, Instead of the Central, Realty. Ca. the Shanghat Land & Finance Ca. had been collecting the rents, the tenants stating that the order had been' made against the Central Realty Ca. and not the Shanghai Land & Pinanee Ca. fo which they would continue to pay rent.

On August 16, witness stated, the defendant company sent notices to the tenants telling them to pay rent! to Mr. Okamoto and three days later, when an injunction against the com:

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account