There could hardly be a greater contrast in musical composition than Beethoven's 7th Symphony and the Chopin Piano Concerto (Havsky at the piano on Sunday). In fact it seems more than cruel tp Chopin to perform any. of his works after such sustained heights as Beethoven achieves in his symphonies. The complete triteness of Chopin's musical expression is brought into full limelight. When we listen to a Chopin programme our admiration is focused on his facile, melodic and rhythmic inventiveness but, as in Sunday's concert at the Lyceum, when we first listened to the working of a great genius, his music fades into the category of tinkling virtuosity.
There is in this Concerto no development of the subject matter; the orchestra provides a quiet accompaniment end nothing more while the piano indulges in exquisite gyrations and nothing more. Had Chopin written this as a free fantasia for piano and orchestra we might be content to listen to so slight a piece Dut as a serious work of art, as the revelation of genius, as the unfolding of a musical germ developed into a complete whole of beauty, we must listen in vain. But Chopin was a shallow man. and unfortunately a shallow musician. How different it is to Iisten to Beethoven.
In the 7th Symphony, Beethoven starts with an idea, very near I believe to Wagner's "apotheosis of the dance"; he unfolds his idea before us and then develops it until with the orghestra's final chord we know that the last word has been spoken and that the idea is complete, indivisible and a thing of real beauty.
Beethoven is a line of demarkation in the history of m In that written before his life the enjoyment lies solely in aural reception, we can blank our minds and become all ears: but with Beethoven and those that follow after, the intellect and ears share equal parts in true' appreciation. Beethoven wrote with his mir and with his emotions, his must complex and our reception must be with more than ears alone if we are Following the interruption_of the! to savour in, full all that Beethoven intended. Of the ormer type of music the Corelli Converto-Grosso is a masterly example.
Maestro Paci; gave a perfect exposition of this thesis. His control of tempo, the evenness of tone and/the complete balance of all the parts of the orchestra with the solo instruments were perfectly understood and expressed. The most noticeable thing of the concert was the orchestra's growing ascendancy in theiņ rendering of the music in front of them and their increased sympathy with it—
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.