In the "battle of brains" we have several immense advantages. Brains thrive om freedom; they wither in an atmosphere of tyranny. We need not, perhaps, be unduly afraid of the brain-power of a State whose dominant party is recruited from the sweepings of the streets or of a country which has expelled or impris+ soned much of its science and learning, points out the "Economist." But we need to ask ourselves whether we too make the best use we might of the native abilities of the people.
One of the weaknesses uncovered by the war which cannot fail to strike the observer in Britain is the serious shortage of talent in every walk of life. It is not merely the usual phenomenon that genius is rare and that "there is plenty of room at the top," there are many fewer men of real ability at the top of every profession and vocation than there were, say. 25 years ago. In the Civil Service, there are a few excellent, but over-worked. men at the head, but there seem to be very few brilliant young men emerging like the Beveridges, the Stamps and the Salters of the last war.
In industry, as has frequently been bemoaned. there are very few men who can be relied upon for a difficult job of production. Familiarity certainly makes the picture more contemptuous than is strictly accurate; but it is hardly possible to deny that the field of selection for posts of real leadership is uncommonly narrow. Few foreigners, few observers from our own Dominions, would have any hesitation in identifying what is it in our national structure that imposes this arbitrary decimation of the candidates for leadership; it is our peculiar educational system.
Pedagogically, we need have no cause for shame: British education is weak on the technical side, but on the whole it is as successful a trainer of minds as other national systems. Tt has shown itself readier' than most to experiment with progressive ideas, and it has always recognized the fundamental truth that education comes from the pupil's learning, not from the teacher's teaching.
The peculiar defect of British education is that it perpetuates a caste distinction such as few other countries have. This is the only country in the world where differences in accent (as distinct, of course, from differences in literacy) have a paramount social and economic importance of being obviously different, in Speech and bearing. from the mass of the people is so great that middle-class families will stint themselves of all but necessaries in order to pay the heavy cost of educating their sons in schools whose merit is not educational but purely social,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.