The Archive · 1923

AS THE SIN OF WITCHCRAFT

To the Editor of the Norra-Curxa Dairy News.'"

Sin,—Under the above remarkable heading Mr, Edwin Zunn' has made some interesting observations in regard to the justi: tion or otherwise of revolutions, confining his remarks as to the duties and rights of government officers under such circumstances. As Mr. Zunn deals only with the duties of government cfticers, presumably both civil and military ones, the question has been narrowed down to limits that do not require profound researches into the genesis of revolutions. Mr. Zunn may be perfectly right in his opinion that the officers who caused the revolt in Wuchang in 1911 had no justification for rebelling against the government and that: they should have remained loyal servants. But he raises the larger question as tv whether ''government officers"' ever have any right to rebel and: answers it in the negative.

Few students of history will be able to subscribe te such a doctrine. It is true that, under ordinary circumstances, the first' duty of government officers is te obey the lawful orders of their superiors. Generally speaking this fundamental law tends to make automatons of government servants. They are not particularly required to think and reflect, and as for criticizing the commands given them, such a thing is subversive of the discipline required by local servants. The consequences of such a fundamental and possibly unavoidable law are, that the majority of government officers, particularly' in the army and navy, gradually lose whatever individuality they may have formerly possessed and act more or less. blindly in obedience to the orders given' them. But some of them never succeed in suppressing their individuality, and it is these Tat ter who, if circumstances become such that they cannot any longer conscientiously obey orders, revolt! against authority. They may not themselves start the revolt. Generally speaking revolutionary' movements have their origin causes unrelated to the welfare of government officers." They lie far deeper; and if the movement! concerns the welfare of the people, who may have just cause for revolting against their rulers; then the most of there jovernment. officers" whose individuality have not been suppressed by constant blind obedience will probably take sides with the revolutionaries. If they do so, are they then performing an immoral act or are they, considering that they are supporting the justified claims of the people as against their oppressors, obeying' a law which must override the obedience hitherto implicitly rendered an oppressive government?

Revolutionary history answers this question. Under certain circumstances ''government officers" have not only a moral right but a moral duty to revolt! against government. Whether the conduct of the military' officers in Wuchang in 1911 was justified by the then prevailing' circumstances is a question that does not concern the central point in Mr. Zunn's interesting letter, in which he lays down the fundamental law that "obedience and loyalty are the unwritten code for the government officers of any country and any kind of constitution and they should not be allowed to meddle in political affairs in' general, outside of what they ard commissioned to take care. of."

Those who know English, French, American, Portuguese, Central-American and recent' German history will not be able t> agree with Mr. Zunn, I am, etc., Gorpius Nietsex.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account