In the case of Beck and Pa Lithograpbing Ca. v. Colorado {ting and Elevator Ca., suppra, Ci Jeuit Judge Sanborn, after announc ting the general principle gover the construction of cantiacts to ect that stipulations as time of their performance are "necessarily of their essence unless {clearly appears in the given euce./ from the expressed stipulation in he contract or the nature of its rl] ject-matter, said: tion of of the ces mies of the Gectied-of the tmsence of the [otae time of performance
the suntrotting consideration: han been Bnd cure tobe to x0 dee'de and close rat hae nniuel penalty one vot he indicted nor wereaonaile dame amine this contract for the purpose of ascertaining whether, if time be regarded as of its essence, penalty will be inflicted upon the defendant or unreasonable damages recovered. It is apparent that when this contract was entered into, the plaintiff voluntarily agreed to reduce defendant's total indebtedness to the bank in the amount of $2,127.78. This indebtedness was to be discharged by payments spread over a period of three years, aggregating $7,350.00, and in consideration of such payments being made when they fell duc, plaintiff agreed to forgive and cancel the demand note for $2,127.78 upon the termination of the contract and return the same to the defendant, and in addi ti thereto, to rebate 2 per cent. interest on the $7,350. Defendant, therefore, had it within his power under this contract, if he fully performed the same, to reduce his acknowlezed indebtedness of $9,477.78 in the sum of $2,127.78 with a rebate of 2 per cent. interest on the payments which he was required to make, Defendant failed to make the $750 payment on January 1, 1925, and the plaintiff now claims that it was then gtd there released from its obligation to return this demand note to the defendant or to rebate to him the 2 per cent interest on his notes aggre gating $7,350 upon the termination of the contract, before, arises istence upon the part of the plaintiff, that defendant pay this demand note for §2,- 127.8, {s inflicting a penalty or Ime Beeme' ome quite clear that if the sing unreasonable damages,
defendant is now required to pay that which he had admitted in this contract was due and owing to to plaintiff! on December 27, 1923, Defendant as no one to blame but him-for the situation in which he is now placed. He agreed by this contract that he would make these payments on the days on which they Became due and payable, and it was only upon such condition that he was to corn and receive back from the plaintiff his demand note for $2,127.78. In other words, defendant given an opportunity to reduce his indebtedness to the plaintiff in the amount of this demand note by making several payments on the days on which they fell due, and plaintiff had the clear right to insist that if defendant failed to male such payments on the days specified, that than and in such case the plaintiff would not release or discharge the defendant from his obligation to pay the demand note with 7 per cent. interest. The very nature of the eon-tract leaves no room for doubt but that such was the intention of the parties. It was the only way in which the defendant was to escape from liability to pay this demal note. Regarding this stipulation to the time of payment as of the essence of this contract, inflicts no penalty upon the defendant because it does not require him to pay any more than he admitted that he owed the plaintiff, neither docs it impose upon him damages of any sort for the reason that the plaintiff is got ting only what was admittedly due it, and the defendant is being quired to pay. only that which he unitted that he owed to the plain tiff. Tt is true that the defendant loses his privilege and right under the contract to decrease his indebtedness to the plaintiff in a very substantial amount, but tie loss fo such right can only be attributed to defendant's own fault and negligence in failing to scrupulously and pun-equally observe his under takings whereby such right was to be secured to
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.