The Archive · 1941

Opinion of Justice Feetham

Following discussions on the subject. witness said they proceeded to Prepare further memoranda, he, him-Self, preparing a very exhaustive one which he voiced the option ém= Phatically "that both' in. law: and equity. We considered that unregisfered Jand "in. the Setlement or Within ite boundaries was liable the time was desi paign for the exchange of old fang-tans into other titles. the Council entered into an agreement with them. to make the required survey of the and to assist them in their work in exchange for information supplied by them to the Council. This was done, and they provided each other with the information required and the old informal titles were acknowledge" purely as prima facie evidence of ownership.

Mr, Bryan then asked witness if Justice Feetham intended to express the opinion that unregistered oF fan-tan land was not taxable. Witness replied that there was no men~ tion in the report that unregistered land was not assessible, but rather that it was not assessed, He added. that in his discussions with Justice Feetham ths latter never stated any thing to the contrary. In fact, he declared. he would have been very much surprised to hear Mr. Justice Feelam express a divergent view. owing to their discussions on: the matter. Witness said that Mr, Justice Feetham expressed a fact, not a legal opinion. Justice Feetham, he asserted, had never expressed the opinion. ther verbally or in writing. that fan-tan land was not taxable, and had shown surprise that it was not. taxed, 'Without going further, witness said. that as a result of the suggestions of Justice Feetham. Mx. Harper and he Prepared the memorandum which' ultimately led the Council to levy the land tax on fan-tan land,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account