The Archive · 1940

Periodically Chronic

"Broadway Melody"

Worthy Representative of Whirlingly Musical Type Aristocrats of Harmony Tomorrow at Farren's Farren's, styling themselves as the "House of Surprises," are presenting tomorrow the Aristocrats of Harmony in a series of musical selections, In the recurrent, or periodically, chronic, case of "Broadway, Melod: the advantage to Western white civilization of a showing, shall we say, in Batavia or, Idzuaan seems rather less apparent, writes a contributor to the New -York "Times." Not that the picture, with Fred Astaire's and Eleanor Powell's duet and solo dancing, surrounded by a typically splendid Metro Goldwyn-Mayer production, is not a worthy representative of its sumptuous and whirlingly- musica! type, not that its Cole Porver rhythms are not sufficiently universal to be appreciated by the semi-civilized, but simply that its story, if taken literally (as no one does, of course, in the forewarned Occident) might arouse unpleasant speculations in primitive minds as to the sanity of their alleged e-hnological superiors.

It is always the sincerest form of sabotage to analyze the plot of a musical production, and in this case it might be doing an active disfavour to the reader himself, if thereby he might be deprived of the sheer, unmental pleasure of following the intricate arabesques of sophisticated rhythm which the startling Astaire still manages to tap out with his not yet superannuaied toes. embracing comedy effects, Ameri importations of musical comedy numbers, and choral effects, said to be without rival in the Orient. Thi: male quartet are in excellent voice, their timing to the dot and their vocal repartee smooth and spirited.

Now well into their second month the Hartnells, Sandra and Fredric, move from success to success, bringing out bright notes from their extensive and apparently inexhaustible Draughtsman of Dance Pumps A draughtsman of the dance pumps, Mr. Astaire will tire only those people who, after so long a time, do Ginally tire even of the most astound. ing choreographic virtuosity. Miss Powell, so long as she is on the dance floor, is a worthy contrapuntal companion in the inexorably logical patterns which Mr. Astaire executes on a waxed floor, although, in the occational dramatic passages which must ensue, even in a "Broadway Melody, she tends to wear set expressions, and to turn her smile off and on, like an essentially unamused neon.

"Gulliver's Travels"

This, the smartest Disney feature, is at the Metropol today.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account