The Archive · 1941

The Scientist's View

To the Editor of the "Norta-Cuwa Dairy New:

Sin—It is probably a sheer waste of time to answer your correspondent Etxos, whose letter appears in your issue of May 19, at least as far as he and his ilk are concerned, for it has always been my experience that people who think as he does are unable to appreciate, let alone answer, any logical arguments brought against the hard-shelled position they have taken up. Invariably their method is to ignore such arguments and to fall back on a further reiteration of their time-worn dogmas, which always beg the whole question by starting with assumptions that are as unwarranted as they are impossible of proo!

Nevertheless, since their position is so largely based on fallacies, it might be as well to subject their teachings and preachings to the cold light of reason and to expose them for what they are, if only to save those who are unable to see through the smoke-screens that they always put up from falling into error.

To start with, your correspondent Euros says that it is a self-evident fact that all human beings are born evil, otherwise why do all men commit evil? This is a typical example of the kind of logic, or rather lack of logic, used by such thinkers as Euros. Even if we grant (which I emphatically do not) that all men commit evil, it does not logically follow that they are born evil. Many men smoke, but I have never heard of a baby being born with a cigar in its mouth. Many men and women indulge in irregularities against our laws governing sex intercourse, but surely even Erros would not go so far as to argue that a new-born baby is an adulterer or an adulteress?

No, people are not born wicked, although most of them die wicked. Sin is not hereditary, any more than is tuberculosis. A few decades ago medical science believed and taught that people inherited tuberculosis from their infected parents, Now we know that at most all that can be inherited in connection with this disease is a tendency to contract it, or, rather, ą weakness in' combating it.' So with wickedness. A child born of wicked parents placed in a favourable environment may live a blameless life entirely independent of any Christian teaching. Children become wicked by imitating the grownups that surround them, and evil by contact with evil without corrective training as they grow up.

But, apart altogether from the foregoing aspect of the question under discussion, one may ask, "What is sin?" The' answer to this is that practically all the things we call sins are acts or practices that militate against the smooth working of our social order. If men are to live safely and happily in communal groups, as is their natural tendency, handed down to them from prehistoric times, then such things as theft, murder, adultery and related activities must be proscribed as evils; but in Nature none of these things are evil. Not only is it perfectly natural for a living organism to take what it needs regardless of ownership, to kill, to indulge in free sex' intercourse and the like, but it is often absolutely necessary for it to do so in order to survive and propagate its kind.

Primitive men, however, learned that giving free rein to these impulses regardless of how such action might affect other members of the communities into which they had formed for better protection, led to the disruption of those communities; and so they were tabooed, in course of time being designated as sins. Members of a community who violated these taboos had to be dealt with in order to preserve them (the taboos) and the community. Hence the idea of punishment. But the period of man's development that proceeded the evolution of such ideas was so vastly greater than the few tens of thousands of years that have elapsed since this taboo system became prevalent. that instincts acquired in the period still persist. The latter period is of too short a duration for adherence to the arbitrarily-imposed taboos to have become instinctive. Hence, left entirely to himself, without training of any kind, and without example to follow, a id will follow the inties of blood, the evil eye and all the other hocus-poons with which men deluded themselves before they began to discover the real facts about Nature and the world in which we live, If sin demands punishment, as Erros would have us believe, then all I can say is that God's punishment machinery is hopelessly inefficient in view of the countless crimes, both individual and collective, of mankind that go unpunished, at least in the present life, Then, too, why should only some people be punished in this life, but the mass be punished in a problematical future existence And, if God wants to punish mankind on a wholesale scale. why does he use such foul instruments as the tyrants who are now overruning Europe Why does he not just turn loose a few good earthquakes, volcanic eruptions or tornadoes, and make a clean quick job of it?

Messrs. RANKIN, Parsi and OLEOS must give humanity something better, more acceptable to the reason, more in keeping with humane ideas and less atavistic than this religion they preach if they would have man turn away from what they call his wickedness! Such doctrines have always failed and always will fail to bring man to a realization that most of the calamities that befall him are the natural results of his failure properly to regulate his social organization and inter-racial relations. Only when he directs his intelligence and energies wholeheartedly to correcting these will peace, universal happiness and prosperity prevail.

What really matters is man's duty to man, By all means let us have sacrifice, but not a stupid useless orifice to appease an irate Rather let us have the sacrifice of one's own personal interests for the benefit of one's fellow beings. I have no quarrel with that part of Christianity which teaches that one should love one's neighbours as oneself.

Finally, 1 must offer a most em-photic protest to the statement made by your correspondent R. J. HassaLı in your issue of May 20 to the effect that, because the most civilized countries in the world today are all Christian, it was Christianity that gave them their advanced civilization. Our advanced civilization is due directly to the labours and discoveries of scientists, who, so far from being backed' by the Christian Church, were fought and persecuted every step of the way as they led man out of his ignorance and superstition. Now that science has won the fight and delivered humanity from the darkness that engulfed it, it is just a bit too much that the credit should be given to Christianity rather than to the men who in their efforts to achieve this deliverance suffered so much at the hands of Christian bigots.

ARTHUR DE C. SOWERBY.

Shanghai, May 21,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account