Taxation Scheme Suggested To the Editor, of the with tee, a Grad amine] to ae mates of the sutabte one difference in the vale of the Hong protection. If they are needed ther Kong dollar and the Shanghai dollar, then it is obvious that every Briton in.
Any discussion by laymen of this were done, then taking re-this port of military age should World War I at its present stage, muheration on 'a. monthly basis tae cither on the way there, or to some is apt to appear presumptuous oF
"Nonm-Cintia Dany News"
Sim—With the British Empire fac ing the greatest crisis in Its history, immediate steps should be taken to censure that the British Community. In Shanghai puts forth every effort to make its contribution a worthy one, Now that it has been made clear that British of pure European descent who are of military age can enlist Hongkong and" Singapore and possibly even in Shanghai, it can safely be left to the United Servic Association to see that those eligib Join uy fein be placed at the disposal of the United Services Association.
While every praise should be given to those who have organized the Centrol British War Fund, and arrangements for the purchase of War Bonds, and even more praise to those who have actually contributed, such voluntary efforts left entirely to the whim of the donor must necessarily be a mere drop "la the ocean compared with what could and should be raised, Tt has been stated that any com. pulsory levy would require an act of Parliament though one would have thought In view of the powers, niven to the Executive in Great, Britain that it could be done by an Order in Council, However there may be ways of making a voluntary. scheme fairly compulsory and I suggest that we start with a voluntary scheme on the following lines, 'Q) An excess. profits contribution from BHUsh: Companies (2) AW remuneration" or ccontribittion from British "sul It cannot be denied that enormous profits have been made by many focal British Companies since July 1937 and even greater profits since September 1939 and "that these profits are largely or entirely due war either here or in Europe, There is not necessarily anything wrong in making profits in war tims Its often Inevitable and no one would 5 not be Tun as efficiently as possible what is wrong is that the Company should be allowed to keep them all, and it would not be allowed in any country in the world except] China, Therefore T suggest an ex-055 profits contribution of 60 per ent, of profits in excess of either: a et cent. on the'
1 profit of (en als aR a PO a ihe sai ever" the Company may elect Thus a Company could elect either (a) or (b) whichever were the greater as the basis on which to make their excess profits contribution, Shareholders would therefore be entitled to have 10 per cent, of the Capital available for distribution (or the pre-war profits if they were greater than 10 per cent), before riy' excess profits contribution be~ came payable.
Lam told that 60 per cent, of such eéxtess profits is too small a percent—age and that in nearly all countries the Government takes 100 per cent, If that is s0, then it could be arranged that the 60 per cent, excess profits contribution were made retractive to include profits for the year 1930, "In eases where Companies did not retain sufficient reserves to be able 10 pay the whole of such contribution, then the balance could be carried' forward as a charge against excess profits for the year 1940, und in such" way the excess profits. contribution for 1940 would be greater' than 60 per cent, If any one considers this" is an. excessive burden on shareholders it should again be reiterated that. there would always be available for Aistribution 10 per cent, on the sub~ scribed capital (or the pre-war profits if they were greater than 10 per cent.) and in addition 40 per cent, of the excess profits, Can anyone expect more on his capital in war time? Ought anyone to ex. pect as much?
Furthermore, in order to com= pensate for the depreciation in value of the Chinese Dollar and place Companies with their capital In Chinese dollars on a fair basis with Companies whose capital is in Sterling, T suggest that the figures all be converted into Sterling at the average rate of exchange for the: year. I know that this would con Siderably reduce the amount of excess profits contribution that would be made to the War Fund, but it is better to start in a. small' way and be fair and equitable than to propose anything that would be drastic and harsh, In regard to the salaries and renumneration contribution, we could do better than adopt the rates: contribution would be 4 per cent. on {ie first $1,500 and 10. per cent. on the remainder after deducting aliow= ances which will be $900 for a bachelor, and $1,500. fora. married man without children, and. $200" for och child under 18, "Thus a Dachelor "whose total remuneration was $1,300 a month would pay $24 a month. if it were $5,000 2 month he would' pay $220 "a month, 'A married man with no. children whose remuneration was' $1300 month "would pay "nothing. On $2,000 a "month the would: pay $20; on $3,000" "he "would "pay "300; $5,000" he' wound pay" 200, 'A'married man with two children whose remuneration is §2,100 a month fess would pay nothing, On $3,000 month he would pay $90 and 45,000 a month he: would pay $200.
'This basis would' work' no undue hardship on anyone ana would leave great number of lower-pald people Untouched, Brith Companies could scare thority to deduct the amount of their from. their British em a
contribution monthly and remit it to the War Fund, In regard to British employees of foreign Companies and British subjects in business for them= selves, we Would have to rely. heir honour to remit their contribu detail because it' someone' puts fave gone Into the plan in so
paper a concrete plan itis much casher To' get to work.
suggest that we put this plan, or modification of it, into operation at once, and 1 invite those willing to help, especially one or two chars tered "accountants, "to communicate with me.
view of the fact that some legal enactment may be necessary (though hope it will' not) if the voluntary lan is not largely supported, T hav sent copies of this letter to HEM. Am= bassador, to. Sir Kingsley Wood, Chancellor of the Exchequer, and to all members of the China 'Com mittee in the House of Commons. have also sent' them a table showing the profits made. by' several repre: sentative British Companies. in 1996 and 1030 together with market prices fof the shares in those years, so that they may have some ied of the stuns If anyone who has read this letter so far is engaged in calculations as 10 how much it will cost him and is) possibly bristling fear and. indignation, T would like to bring him back to the realities of the situation and conclude by quoting from the tele-gramme from the United States Ambassador to Great Britain, Mr. Joseph Kennedy, reported. in your issue t0- day, in appealing for funds for the American Red Cross in Great Britatn, "Everything indicates that Britain Will be called upon to meet the greatest siege in the history of ma Shanghai, June 25.
OF. Hanns.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.