The Archive · 1941

Debate Left to Lawyer

After witness had assorted that the collection of the tax was not provided for in the Land Regula. tions. and Mr, Justice Feetham's Report, Mr. Bryan retorted. that neither the Land Regulation nov Mr. Justice Feetham's Report gave witness. immunity from paying the tax, suggesting to "witness that his statement was "entirely untrue," Witness replied that he would leave his Tawyer to debate with Mr. Bryan og he was disposed to, do so. Me, Bryan followed this up by pointing. out to witness that he should not make straements about what is In the Land Regul when in fact they, are not th Witness readily admitted that he required that use of Municipal highways, light, water, ele, "You do not want' to pay the' Land Tax and want to receive all these benetts without "paying the price," Mx, Bryan then put to witness, who replied that he was paying the Municipal rates, you want to get vl the Munl~ cipal facilities and you don't want to pay for them. 1s that it?" Mr. Bryan, shot at witness, who replied that he would be willing to. pay if required to do so under the Land Regulations, After further questions counsel told witness that many Chinese owners of "fan-tan" land in the Settlement were paying land tax to the Council. Witness said he wag not aware of it.

Mr, Bryan then severely took wit ness to task for applying to the Chinese Ratepayers Association for assist once in the case and for having it referred to Chungking. Witness said he had not personally solicited the intervention of Chungking In the matter, jut the Chinese Ratepayers Ass0- elation did, at your request." Mr. Bryan then asked, to which witness replied th ibis had nothing to do with the case and refused to answer the question, Mr. Bryan pressed fo Jan answer and witness on. the fugue: ion of his counsel replied that he only asked the Ratepayers' Associa. tion whether he should pay the Land Tax, and they had replied verbally Jand'in writing that he should not,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account