To the Editor of the "Norra-Catna Datty News."
Sir,—As in your issue of March 5 you returned to your attack against the British Associated Chambers of Commerce, I trust that you will see your way to publishing this letter.
In your previous articles you have assumed that your pretation of the Washington treaty is the correct one. It would, therefore, appear that the British Cham-! bers were unfortunate in not consulting you on this subject before their conference. Before framing their resolution, however, the Committee of the Associated Chambers took steps to consult what they considered to be the best sources of information as to the interpretation of the treaty, realizing that any resolution not on, its correct interpretation would serve no useful purpose. Having obtained the best opinion available, they framed their resolution according-
In your "Notes and Comments' ct March 5 you again endeavoured to show that the Hongkong Shanghai Bank are out of sympathy with the Chambers and you baser this endeavour on your interpretation of the Chairman's speech. The speech was addressed to the shareholders of the Bank who are mostly business men and who, I think, are not likely to place the same construction on his remarks as you have. In any case, the resolutions which were adopted by the British Associated Chambers of Commerce were approved by the individual Chambers, including Hongkong, and passed unanimously, and the resolution with reference to the 2} per cent, surtax was, as has already been stated officially, approved of in principle by the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation.
The point which you entirely ignored in the Chairman's speech was that nothing could be done to assist China from outside in exis ting circumstances. The Chambers' resolution does not deal with existing circumstances but with circumstances as they will be if the 2} per cent. surtax is granted. Xour hasty ignoring of this essential difference is on a par with your ill-considered treatment of other aspects of the question.
Amongst these other aspects is the fact that the Chambers' resolutions never contemplated or suggested the funding of China's unsecured indebtedness as a measure to be taken irrespective of, or unconnected with, the disbandment of troops. The two were linked together as separable parts of a single This fact your comments on the resolution have deliberately concealed from the public, and you have allowed a letter to appear in your columns, without any comment, suggesting that the Chambers have
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.