The Archive · 1923

China Fairy Tales

To the Editor of the "Norrn-Cama Dairy News."

Sir,—A good deal of gratuitous advice and information on China is being given out' in technical and trade journals at Home to British manufacturers and others just now. Certain of these self-appointed advisers on Chinese matters have come to regard themselves aa such high authorities on China that. they have adopted "China" as part, of their name, and in letters to the "Times" and other papers sign themselves og "T. Brown Smith (China)," ete. In many instances the knowledge possessed by these individuals has been acquired by a brief and often hectic visit to one or other of the cities in China or in Hongkong. The information and advice so generously given out by these gentlemen is often very amusing to those who know anything of China. In a recent number of a well-known—technical journal there appeared an. article on exchanges, native banks, and the land development ''slump" in Shanghai. Another writer in the same issue gave the name of 4 gentleman as that of the best knowm builder of railroads and pioneer of communications in the Far East. Now, it happens that that gentleman had not the remotest connexion with the building of a single mile of railway anywhere in Asia. To cap all this a letter appeared in the '"Engineer" of February 2, which I enclose herewith, and written by a Mr.. Cetil S. Howsin, who spent a few months in Peking. On the strength of that short stay Mr. Howsin tries to teach ug Chinese, tells us the position of "a bull's-eye on a target, and advises British manufacturers to ignore present political conditions in China. One wonders whether Mr.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account