The Archive · 1941

Unequal Taxation Discussed

Council Official Stresses Difficulty of Taxing Income and Profits at Press Conference

Shanghai, Feb. 7. difficulty of ascertaining the actual income and profits of various individuals and the business of different' nationals in Shanghai was emphasized by Mr. G. Godfrey Phillips, Secretary and Commissioner-General of the Shanghai Muni ipal Council, at fa press conference held at the Administration Building yesterday afternoon.

Considerable publicity having been given to the question of equality of taxation recently, Mr. Phillips disclosed that the Council has appointed an international committee to study the matter.

The committee which will hold its first meeting on February 11, consists Messrs, C, 8, Franklin, American egal practitioner and former chairman of the Council: Mr. J, R, Jones, 'a British barrister of the Jaw firm of Ellis and Hays, a former secretary of the Council well versed in English rating law on which the Council's rating system has been built; Mr, F, Meyers, who has' given much time and study to the study of Coun: cil taxation; Mr, 0. Okamoto, former Japanese' councillor and lega) practitioner; and Mr, J. H. Sun, Chinese chartered accountant and assistant general-manager of the Sin Hua Trust and Savings Bank who has had considerable experience in the real estate business in Shang-hal, In reply to'n question as to why the name of Mr, ES, Little, has not been added to the list Mr. Phillips said that it was dimeult for him to answer why the Council had selected the persons mentioned to serve on the committee, One answer, he thought, might be that Mr, Little has committed himself to a particular tax problem and might communicate his views to the committee instead of actually serving on it, 'A. Constitutional Matter Mr, Phillips was asked if breweries could' not be licensed and replied in _Ahe affirmative, but pointed out that when Heensing a business like that the Council would have to assume more responsibility for supervising production which would entail un in" crease to its stof and employment of Inspectors, He did not see any objection to breweries being taxed and agreed that they came. within the ealegory of factories, The committee hho explained, has under consideration the licensing of occupations not Licensed at present, Anot%er questioner asked whether was not true that certain ratepayers held a large number of votes, suggesting that the Council could save time by summoning a meeting of the big vote holders to decide Municipal affairs, Mr, Phillips pointed out that would not allow himself to be drawn Into constitutional or political discussions, Tu a commentary current Municipal topies Me, Phillips is sometimes said that the Council does not pay enough attention to answering criticisms of ts doings made by the public in letters the papers, This time, T want to try and answer a criticism before it is made, There has been considerable publicity given lately to the question ff equality of taxation, and the Council has appointed a Committee to go Into this question, 'The Members of the Committee are Mr, C. S, Franklin, Mr, J, R, Jones, Mr. N, F, Moyers, Mr, 0, Okamoto' and Mr, J. H, Sun, Now, some. people will perhaps' com. plain that the members of this Comitteo are people who have been too closely associated with the Council, The Council realized that this eritieism might be made, and T want to take this opportunity of explaining to you why the Cotinell appointed a Committee consisting of people who were experts in Council affairs, The Job that the Committee has 0 do is a very diMecult one and it has to be Gone very quickly if the Committee's report is to be ready for adoption in for the Annual Meeting of Ratepayers in April, 'The Council felt that the job could only be done by people who could start straight away, having a good knowledge of the exist= ing system and of rating. principles and practices, Mr, Jones is a former Secretary of the' Council, with a knowledge of English rating law on which our rating system has been built up, Mr, Franklin and Mr, Okamoto are not only familiar with Council. affairs but also have legal Knowledge of practices in countries other than Great Britain, Mr, Meyers has given much study and thought to the problem involved Mr. Sun, a Chartered Accountant, is "Assistant General Manager of' the Sin-Hua Trust and Savings Bonk, Ltd, with experience in the Real Estate business in Shanghai,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account