The publication of the protest concerning the rates charged by the Foreign Y.M.C.A. to residents in the building opposite the Race Course, and Dr, McCracken's letter complaining of the action of this journal in publishing it again draws attention to the affairs of that institution. Lest it be claimed that the Foreign Y. is in the nature of a private club and that its domestic questions are no matter for public discussion, it should be pointed out that, in addition to the gifts made by Mr. Crane, former U.S. Minister to China, Capt. Robert Dollar and the International Committee in New York, the Shanghai public did its bit by subscribing no less than Tls. 200,000. The public of Shanghai is consequently very interested to knowing how an institution made possible by its donations is being managed, and though the board of trustees of the Foreign Y.M.C.A. appear to think that the.concern they control is a private one, there are many, including this journal who hold an entirely opposite view.
It is a fact that there is dissatisfaction amongst residents at the Foreign Y.M.C.A, at the increases which have already occurred and the one which was announced in June last. The charges made in the protest are such that they should be investigated, for if it is true as the compilers of that document aver that "food and room rent charges" are "obviously built up to cover the non-profit producing activities of the Y." then the considerations which led he public of Shanghai to subscribe so handsomely sixteen years ago ne longer prevail and the intention of the donors to provide a place where men could live reasonably cheaply has been ited. The protestants complain that they are facing increases "out of all proportion to the in-Creases being levied by the better class boarding houses." That is either a statement of fact, or it is not, and the people who assisted in making the Foreign Y.M.C.A. possible will naturally want to know the truth Of the matter, A correspondent to this journal suggests that in the case of another protest as far back as 1939 it was proposed to establish Residents"
Residents' Representative Committee as a the Trustees and the residents. The story of how that matter was dealt with is not very but it is claimed that to as they have every This is by no means the has arisen during the existence in Shanghai of Y.M.C.A., and sight must not be lost fact that there is probably something to be said for the Trustees in this matter. It is..not to be assumed that the protestants' case allow of the fostering of misunderstandings which it should be their bounden duty to remove.
It is perhaps unfortunate that the compilers of the protest thought fit to end up with a minatory paragraph threatening to appeal to the Y.M.C.A. headquarters in New York. Their request for a sub-committee of investigation seems reasonable enough, and the Trustees should welcome, the opportunity of putting their case before the representatives of the residents rather than maintain a dogged silence which can do nothing but breed suspicion all round. The impression gained during the history of the institution is that there has been too much of the "take it or leave it" attitude on the part of those responsible for the management of the Foreign Y. That impression should be removed, and that can best be done by the Trustees lening to the representatives of the residents who consider they have grievances. After all the raison d'étre of the institution is to render service to its members at the most reasonable rates possible and if that is not being done, as the protestants allege, then the Y.M.C.A. is not fulfilling its mission.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.