The Archive · 1875

Before R. A. Mowar, Esq

Toxo Cuzoxa v. W. H. Parra, Plaintiff claimed $37, for work done materials supplied, in July, 1873, His Hoxoun asked defendant if ho admitted the debt?

Defendant replied in the affirmative, bot said he refused to pay the account until plaintiff returned a coat and waistcoat, which hho sent to be repaired about a year ago, If plaintiff returned those articles, ho was will ing to pay the amount now.

Plaintitt informed the Court that when te clothes referred to were brought to his shop, which was about 18 months ago, he refused to do avy more work for defendant, until paid the outstanding bill, Some time alter. wards defendant's boy came and asked for them, and they were given to him, Defendant—I have never received the clothes. I sent my coolie for them yesterday, but be could not obtain them.

Phe coolie was called, and stated that he went to the plaintiff's shop yesterday, ad asked for the coat and waistcoat, and was told they had been returned about @ mouth before.

Plalatif's partner was next examined, and Aoposed—Tho coolie came to our shop yesterday, and asked me for a coat and waistcoat, Ttold him they had beau returned about a year ago, I thought to defendant's boy.

Defendant's boy, next called, dep went for the doties once, long time ago, I was told they wore not finished. I have not been for them since, because I have never deen sent.

His Hoxovr said that as the defendant admitted that the goods bad been supplied and didn't object to the prices, the plaint was entitled to judgment. Any claims the defendant had against the plaintiff he would have to prosecute before the Mixed Court. If the case was a clear one, ho (his Honour) would not put the parties to the inconvenience of a fresh suit in another Cour, but would deal with it there and then, but hho must say that the probabilities were greatly in favour of the clothes having bern returned at some time or other during the Jong interval that had elapsed. ''ho plaintiff, duit of the defendant's old. loti—ho sup: who was a tailor, was hardly likely to retains

posed they wore old?

Defendant—Yes.

His Hoxovr—Well, they could not have been of much service to the plainti, and there is hardly any market here for second: hand clothes. It was a great deal more Likely that the plaintiff had, as he said, determine to do no more work for defendant till ho was paid for what he bad done already, and let the clothes in question untouched till they were fetched away. However, that was a point the Mixed Court would decide, when the de fendant brought his action.

Defendant said he would not bring soy action.

is Hoxovn asked the value of the old clothes?

Defendant said they were worth from $10 to $12.

His Hoxour said that, as to the balance of $25, there was no reason why that amount should not be paid. He would make an order that the defendant should pay the $37 into Court, and $12, if the defendant wished, should be retained until the judgment of te Mixed Court.

The defendant repeated that be should 204 proceed against the plaintiff in the Mix His Hoxour thereupon gave judgment for plaintiff, for full amount, with casts.

Sept, 220d.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account