The Archive · 1876

The Treaty Consuls

We are not casting any reflection upon the individual members of the Consular Body in Shanghai, when we affirm that, as a practical and executive body, it must always prove ineffective. The functions of the Consuls, as consuls, are of quite a different nature to those which, as members of the Consular Body, they have recently shown a disposition to assume. The true position and fanetion of the Consular Body is deliberative; to assist with their advice, or control by their opinion the more practical boards of administration. That they lave ocersionally stepped out of this province with good effect, we are quite prepared to ad Th justification for it has been the inacti of those with whom the duty of initintive properly lies. If the Council and the Chamber of Commerce abrogate their functions, we may be indebted occasionally to the Consuls for taking them up. Bat we still affirm that the principle is mistaken, and is sure to lead to inconvenience in the end, To take, for instance, two matters which came before the meeting of the 22nd_inst—jhe Harbour Regulations, and a proposed new Jetty line, The preamble to the proposed Harbour Regulations wisely stipulated that the approval of the Chamber of Commerce should be required to their revision, We can scarcely imagine a more useful proviso—as, after all, the Chamber represents the body most interested, The clause however seems to have met the disapprobation of certain of the Consuls. What their reasons for the objections are do not appear; bub one not influenced by official prejudice would see in the approval of the Chamber a guarantee for the practic cal nature of the proposed amendments or, in the opposition of men most ins timately concerned in the welfare of the port, a probably valid reason for their rejection.—Siill more clearly does Cnptain Bixbee's proposal for laying down a fixed limit, beyond which no jetties or pontoons shall be allowed to project into the stream, again appear to us one which should be submitted at the outset to the Chamber and to the Municipal Councils, and come before the Consuls for official sanction fortified with the approval of those public bodies, We sympathise entirely with the object of placing a limit to the extension of jetties, as a useful supplement to the Bund line which has been alrendy approved, and trast the principle will be rigidly adhered to. But the mere passing of the rule will be inconvenient, to use no stronger word, unless practical measures are taken to make the present jetties serviceable. From many causes, which have been often enough recapitulated, the river has Asteriorated. and is deteriorating-.en mpidly that the extension of jetties has been, and still is, constantly neces sary. Wharves and jetties have been themselves very grenily the cause of this harm, but the harm has gone so far that more than negative measures are necessary to check the evil, Dred. gers should make and keep a useful depth of water in front of existing jetties, at the same time that the owners are forbidden to encroach farther on the yarrowing channel; and the respon. sibility of action no less thai that of negation lies on the Hurbour Authorities and on the Government which they represent. Otherwise, to simply forbid extension is to condemn existing jetties to eventual inutility—Another matter in which we regret to see the Municipal authorities set aside, is the question of Chinese proclama. tions, That the Mandarins should dis. like submitting their proclamations to the Council before posting them, is natural; bub the Council have brace tically exercised this check, and it is right and useful that they should do so. It does not require much experience of Chinese officials to recognise that the entrusting to their hands of the right of interference must lead eventually to abuses which will require much judgment and discrimination to set toxights, As the case stands, the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account