Shanghai, May 29th, Before R, A. Mowat, Here v. Aurrep Pcumerox.
This was s claim to recover Tis, 20, for services rendered and money expended; with $3.50 additional, for material supplied, Defendant paid Tis, 10, and the $3.50 into Court, stating that that was the amount he considered himself indebted.
Plaintiff said he was not satisfied with the amount paid into Court, He was then sworn, and depas efenitant engaged the Masonic Hall, to give concerts. The cause of my bringing this summons into Court, is been uso Tcotild not get an answer from the defen with respect to the payment of my. Lill, which I had sent in to him, Lent it by my boy, and he brought it back, opened, saying defendant told him he knew'nothing about That was on the 25th instant, I sent it in again on the 26th, my chit-book being brought back initialed "U.P." I sent th me, late, the same evening, asking about having' the chairs, which I had bore the Club Concordia, returned, received f answer that Me. Plampton would aday, He did not come, last time On Saturday jaying, i€ there was anything the matter with the bill, aut he would call upon I would see what could be done, He idl not call, and L went the same day to the Central Hotel, and sent up my card, 1 hoy came down, and said Mr. Plumpton could not seo me, as he hnd a gentleman with him, I waited, and avon afterwards saw defendant nda Indy come down stairs, and before I is 1 then get to the di y got into
1 ing telling Mr. Plampton where to procure chairs for the hall, and going with my own boys personally to the Club Concordia to obtain them; and clowning the hall before and after the eocerts, I showed defendant by my book that his expenses would be about Tia, 15 per concert, in audition to th tot the hall, but that as no fires were wanted, would be is, 10. lant took the hall for two ets, but it was thought three would be Teharge'T!. 1 for removing chairs from din to the Masonic Hall; cleaning before and after the for myself superintending, fix doing all charges for the first concert cond concert they were exactly the sane, As to the charges being for ench concert separately, Mr. Kingsmill was present at the conversation between myself and Mr. Plump tou on the subject; and 1 have sent for him to come here, but he has not arrived yet.
His Hoxoor—Was there any necessity for ug for cleaning the hall after the frst, also (that is, @ second time) before the e the Flower Show, male wet and dirty by the r quently they all required cleaning for the second concert; and it was, besides, a usual thing to do—to clean the hall properly after being used.
His Hoxour then asked defendant what his account of the matter was?
Defendant said he was led to understand th Tis, 10 were to cover the work done for the coneens intended to be 4 He had no idea that he was to be charg in that way ch concert, He produced a memoran-rom Mr. Gundry, one of the Executive the effect that he lered the charg His Hoxour—Thut is merely an expression of opinion.
Defendant, examined by plaintiff said—You showed me an entry in your book, "lls, 15:25, which you said was the charge for one nigh but in my cage, T understood the Ils, 10 were to cover all three concerts, if three had been given.
fendant then went on to say that he to provide hia own ticket collectors, and to build a platform in the hall at his own cost. He "id not so much object to th extra Ts. 10, an that he wanted to knot what plaintiff had done for the money.
Mr. Kinosuitt, who here came into Court, id, in reply to His Hoxoun—I was present
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.