Mosquito, told hi absence, Lyell cargo? I not the witness Paul in the ce examination on the occasion referred to, wear that he enquired of the other officer Whether Jennings if Hind I have that in my notes. the other officer to whom he referred understood him. to mean Mr. Foster, the inner, a8 they were the only two left on the witness Paul in the course that avy report about the plaintiff Lyell was made to him on the Send January by Mr, Foster, the gunner of the Mosquito? I have no. special statoment in my notes to that effect, beyond the evidence given by C Paul that enquired of the gunner whether Mr, Jen-ort was accurate. amined by Plaintift—Paul and another with Mr. joing up from Fergusson & Cos jetty before me morning of the 22ud of January? Yes, did,—You saw mo on that morning as a marines with i did.—You risener in chs °, of three spoke to mo? Yes.—About what time was this? Between ten and eleven a.m,—In what state was I, drunk or sober? You had appearance of being drunk, PPO. Howanp, examined by Plaintiff—You heard the agreement made with Captain More, about the cotton? Yes, I di called to witness it.—What was the first offer? I don't remomber.—Did I accept the first offer? No, you refused it.—Did I note ay it would not pay mo? Yee, you did,—What was the amount I offered to'take it out for? Witty conte per bale.—Did you hear me say make it $100, and that will be 50 conte per Date for the' 200 bales of cotton on board T'was under the impression that the agreement was for the whole lot—two hundred of cotton,—Did Lieutenant Poulter for Captain fore and yourself to come. on board the Afosquity on Sunday morning, shortly, after bor arrival at wreck?" Yes. you state ax nearly ible wh d between yourself, Capt, Rfore and Lieutenant Poulter? Lieutenant Poulter asked Captain More in my presence what lie intended to do, Capt: More replied, place the entire charge of the wreck in hands, It was Gnally agreed that Capt, More ould return to the wreck and try and come to some arrangement with you to get out the cotton and other cargo. Lieut, Poulter also told Captain More that as you were on board the wreck with your coolies it would be better to make an agreement with you for ralving the cotton and other cargo, #0 as to
Me fosquito.—And what was the final decision goods were to be sent sooypide the Tf an agreement could be made, the
The final deci ion was that Capt. More was to hearing of the impe Consulate, re Annie Gray? Yes, I di the notes produced those you took? Yes, they are the notes.—Did not Captain Paul in the course of his evidence on that occasion swear that, on Sunday the 21st January, he went on board the Annie Gray and saw the master, and that the master told him that ho wished the Bosquito to take charge of the wreck and save the cargo, and that the master told him that he bad' made arrangements with me to pay 50 cents for every bale of cotton I put on board the Mosquito? Yes, Lhave that in my notes.—Did not ti witness Paul in the course of his said evi ence say that, on his arrival at the wreck early next morning, Monday the 22nd January, Mr. Jennings, the paymaster of the Afosquita, told him that during his (Paul's) absence, I had impeded the removal of cargo?" That is in accordance with the notes I took at the hearing.—Did not the Paul, in the course of his cross-examinati on the occasion referred to, swear enquired of the other officer whether Jo report was accurate? T have in my notes following, "I enquired of the officer in charge."—Does not Captain Paul state in his cross-examination that I was arrested but because I would not leav 1 [have in my notes as follows, arrested under, no offence at all, but merely to remove you."" The memorandum of notes taken by mo at Her Britannic Majesty's Court at Chefoo, contains a true statement of what passed in the Court.
Ly, a native diver, examined by Plain-—A.R. Donnelly, interpreter.—Who was it stopped us taking out cargo from the wreck of the Annie Gray? An officer of the gunboat, a tall mau.—-You enw the the main-hatch, when he stopped the officer holding a pistol, at me at discharge of the cotton? It was the same officer, I saw him holding the pistol. Was the cargo then stopped? After that the cargo was stopped.-—When did the coylies onshore? About 3 o'clock in the morning.
Tusa, in the employ of J. Smith, examined by Plaintiffii—A. it. Donnelly, Interprater,—Did you see Smith go on shore, was it before or after the gunboat anchored? I saw Smith go on shore about the same time as the gunboat anchored.—How Tong did he stop on shor Did you hear me tell you to away after they were fini cotton from the Island? I did not hear you.
as I drunk? No, I saw you for some you appeared to have had no liu "This concluded the case for the plaintiff, theCourtadjourned until thefollowingmorning, Mr. Rmsoere asi it wan now his duty to opt. Ath.
open the de \dant's case, The privilege of dressing a jury was not ove they often had in Shanghai, and although he could not say he was sorry to have.that privilege now, he could not help but think that the time of the jury was being wasted in bearing such a trumpery case." He called it a trumpery case because he hoped to be able to show, from the evidence he should call, that it was deserving of that name and ought never to have been brought. What was it the plaintiff bad asked them to decide? Whether or not he was entitled to damages against Captain Paul for taking him away from the wreck, where he was misbehaving himself, in the Mosquito to Chefoo, and then to the Consulate under arrest. As to what took place at the Con-alate, he thought they would be told by Lordship that it was a matter beyond their consideration; they had nothing with that, but the fact that plaintiff was to be paid $100 for getting all the cotton out of the ship, but the jury would not fail to remember that when he was asked if there bad been more than 200 bales whether he would have got all of them out, he replied, that be should not have got out more than 200. Now he should prove to them that the agreement with the plaintiff was that he was to salvo as much of the cotton as he could and put it on board the Mosquito for 60 touts a bale; and by this agreement he unquestionably waved all claim he might have had, or thought he had, as the original salvor tte Grelioe veanel, It was perfectly clear that under the circumstances he (plaintiff) was bound to obey the orders of the master, Captain More, in every respect; and it was no doubt his knowledge of this that caused him to make the agreement with Captain More. Plaintiff set up a claim which wa unsupportable, and, according to his admis ad interfered with the salving of the When the junk came alongside the wreck be interfered and continued to inter-fore during the night; and he threw overboard to be dragged through the w the Island when there i Whatever was the plainti matter it appeared to him a curiot ye the cotton; and when the naval interfered to pr \git overboard they only did what it was their duty to do. They were justified in stopping any proceeding they did not think to be in the interest of the ship, and he thought the jury would believe that their conduct was sriest proper in that would a few words plaintiff had lodged. of the Consul, Blaine not. press those appeals for certain reasons, and one of the reasons was that be charged the Consul of Chefoo with having improperly taken Gown the evidence, That charge, he thought, would go far to damage his ease in the yen, of the jury, rather than advance his interests, Plaintiff had little to complain of, for he was allowed lays to prepare his defence on each of the charges on which as convicted; and his own admission wed that ho did threaten to throw the paymaster overboard, and that he did it cotton from the charges on which pi his own ad 4 not improperly 3 0 briny the charge he lind against the Consul was monstrous in the extreme, Moreover, such charge was totally irrelevant and should not have been made, and instead of bein, in his favour, he thought it would tell very much against Let them now see how plaintiff had tried to vindicate his character, a be alleged was the object of the suit, How could he vindicate his character by the present suit? Notat all, and it was absurd to think that be could, Supposing verdict and damages were awarded him on the ground that his conveyance from the wreck fo the shore and his march to the Consulate was improper, his character would not be Vindicated; the circumstances of his con-Yiction would not have been entered into, and the convictions by the Consul would still be recorded against him. The jury would hear evidence that plai was removed from.
the ship by the distinct orders of Captain More, the master, and all they had to decide was whether his removal was ifiable or hot, If plaintiff was successful in this action his character would not be restored in the east. The convictions against him must be removed before there could be any restoration return to the wreck and see if he could make cot otod of the charges preferred against of his character, and he (plaintiff) was easy in about calving the cotton with IK, W. VarcHss, examined by Plaintiff—Did you receive orders on the 22nd January to imprison me? Yes, I received orders from HB.M. Consul.—About what time? About noon.—Was it not earlier? I don't think it was—You had an opportunity of ing whether 1 was drunk or sober? Yes, I an opportunity.—Waa I drunk or sober? You were sober.—You are positively sure that I was perfectly sober? You had not the 9 pesranca of being drank.—At what time did leave the jail? At 4 o'clock in the evening.
A. BAUERMEIeTEE, examined by Plaintifi—Did you take notes of the.evidence at the him seemed to show that there was some justification for what defendant had done. laintif bad fully described how he was taken from the wreck to the Consulate in the custody of a marine, and for this he claimed Tls. 2,000—Tls. 1,500 for loss of character, and Tls. 500 for loss of busi Personally he could form no idea how plain-if's character had suffered to the extent of 1,500 by the arrest, when he considered his character had not suffered at all by the solemn convictions by the Consul. What was it the plaintiff asked them to believe? He had said he was on the wreck-some hours before Captain More arrived. When Captain More arrived he entered into an his steps to upset those convictions. When they came to consider the credibility or weight to be attached to the plaintiff's evidence, they would find it differed very little in the main facts from that he should lay before them. Plaintiff had admitted that he obstructed the loading of the junk with cotton, and. threw cotton into the sea, and these were the only occasions when the naval officers protested. That plaintiff obstructed the salvage of cargo there could be no doubt, and it was only by the production of firearms that his interference was prevented. Plaintif bad also admitted that he was asked by Captain Paul to leave the ship and refused, and
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.