The Archive · 1879

THE USE AND ABUSE OF SCIENTIFIC 'LECTURES

In an article on the use and abuse of scientific lectures, which appeared a yen ngo in the Quarterly Review, Professor Tyndall's latest utterances were summarised and severely criticised, while a striking contrast was drawn between what was represented as his rash intemperance of thought and Innguage, and the calm moderation of Virchow, The latter author had in the previous September addressed the German Society of Naturalists on the freedom of science in the modern commonwealth, and a translation of his speech appeared shortly afterwards in Nature, where no doubt. many of our renders saw it, Tt was a vigorous protest against the tendency of scientific men to represent natural problems as already solved, and to force their opinions upon public acceptance as full and satisfactory solutions. Tt was in fact a denunciation of dogmatism. The orator particularly marked down for disap-approval the doctrines of spontaneous generation and evolution, and in a special manner condemned the thorough-going enthusiasm displayed by Professor Haeckel, of Jena, who claims that all school teaching shall at once be founded on the evolution theory, with spontaneous generation as its logical pendant. He warns students of nature not to be dazzled by the brillinuey nor seduced by the plausibility of any theory that is not actually proved. Faith should follow knowledge, and theories do not enter the category of knowledge until after laborious verification. At the same time there is but one alternative— spontaneous generation or creatic The mind that definitely rejects one form, by that act accepts the other, with all its necessary consequences. Hence, for the present, the need of that expgctant attitude which the true sceptic maintains, A. trenchant rejoinder has followed from Haeckel, under the title of Frei Wisserschaft und free Lehre. After a caustic criticism of Virchow's competence, he attacks one by one the positions occupied by the orthodox. He asserts that hybridism has been proved not to be the insuperable bar to fertility that it has hitherto been believed to be, and that the productiveness of animals of the same species is not a role without exceptions. He impossibility of defining 0 lower strata of life, one ty passing by insensible gradations into the next, antu between individuals far removed from one another in the differences are found of a char neter sufficiently marked to be called specific. Upon such grounds Haeckel holds the theory of evolution to be fully proved, and thus implicitly as well as explicitly pledges himself to the doctrine of the fortuitous occurrence of the primordial cell, It appenra to be beyond gestion that living beings consisting of but one cell, possess at least the rudiments of intelligence. Haeckel refers the power of conducting borate mental processes possessed by higher animals to the division of labour among myriads of nerve cells all descended in the secular series from the original monad, and in the i vidual from the embryo cell. He retorts Virchow's charge of uncertainty in scientific theories, by asking scorufally what, after all, is certainly trae—except of course the dogmas of the chu These he supposes his antagonist will swallow without a gr i aery of Ichabod over this renunei of independence. Yet few, we imagine, will deny that Vircbow occupies a truly philosophical ground when he insists upon the difference between facts and hypotheses.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account