The Archive · 1878

Tue Reports of the China Merchants

AND ACCOUNTS

Steam Navigation Company afford an instructive commentary on the means which have been pursued of late by the predominant faction in the Empire. Started on the bessis of rendering the position of foreigners in China unendurable, and boasting of their approaching annihilation, it hes now been discovered by its managers that the powers even of a Government may be limited, and that there are regions into which none but the most hair. brained of politicians will step. That in fact Government is ove thing, and commercial enterprise another; and that the attempt to amalgamate the two must of necessity result in injuring the cause of both one and the other. The report of the Company published in 1876 spoke boastfally of the project of establishing a "Grain Convoy and Public Carrying Company," with the object of diverting to China the profits of the traffic. "During several years previously, foreign companies made yearly profits of several millions, but since the establishment of the China Merchants'

Company, their receipts are reported to be sufficient only for their expenses. Their profits have been limited; the drain of the Chinese money is stopped, and the conveyance of merchandise no longer confined to foreign bottoms.—In making the foregoing statements, the Directors do not perversely oppose themselves to public opinion. They are convinced that, by pursuing steadfastly their present line of action it will in the end be proved that, instead of injury great benefit must result from their policy." After two years more of existence it is useful to examine how far these objects have been gained what is the sum of profit which has been diverted to China through the operations of the China Merchants' Company, and what the benefit which has resulted or is likely to result through their policy.

At the beginning we may say that the accounts of the China Merchants'

Company are not remarkable for inci ity, and that their comprehensibility does nut ituprove as time goes on. Tu Europe, where shareholders are at least supposed to have the power of investigating accounts, some little attention is paid to their intelligible rendering. As, however, shareholders of the China Merchants' Company have only contributed 750,000 taels out of capital returned at upwards of five millions, there is probably not much inducement to make them too clear.

Last year, in reviewing the position of the Company, we spoke of the difficulty of ascertaining the meaning of the accounts. Last year's accounts were however lucidity itself compared with those the Company now puts forward, Other changes may likewise be noticed.

Tu the first noticed report, the Directors of the Company spoke. with lan affectation of modesty of their position, They were Directors, they Sid not state how, and "as in duty bound by the laws of. the Company, they have to request that shareholders will proceed to elect in their place others more deserving and capable than themselves." In No. LI, the form of address was somewhat changed; the Directors simply "hope to have the consideration of the shareholders." Nor leaveseventhisappeal out, "It is now five years since the Directors bad the honour to receive instructions from the Earl Li to undertake the management of the Company." They have rendered accounts not as in duty bound, but that the shareholders may be "induced to make themselves acquainted therewith." The want of confidence between the Directors and the shareholders has been growing greater year by year;.and this, if nothing else, is plainly shown in the position of the capital fund.. Ab the time of the first published Report, up to September, 1876, the capital subscribed was 685,000 taels out of a total indebtedness of a little over. two millions. By the next year the amount of share capital bad increased to 730,000 taels, or an increment of 45,000 taels, while the entire indebtedness was increased by nearly three., millions to 4,763,000 taels. During the year just passed, but 20,000 taels have been subscribed from all sources, while the indebtedness of the Company has in+ creased, by some 400,000 taels, to 5,164,000 taels.

Last year, in reviewing the position of the Company, we pointed out that while its property had been increased by the purchase of the S.S.N. Ca. and of property from Messrs, Russell and Ao., the nominal value had been farther increased by about 230,000 taels in addition to the cost price, and that no explanation of this extraordinary result was given in the accounts. No allows ance had been made, moreover, for depreciation, which on property of the nature of that belonging to the Com. pany should at the time of the last report have amounted to about 580,000 taels, This year a still more extras ordinary statement of assets la pat forward. The Aden, originally valued, according to the report of 1876, at 200,000 taels, although a bulk for three years, seems not to have been written off yet, as the overvaluation placed on the fleet in 1877 cannot apparently be otherwise accounted for. The fleet according to the report consists now of 31 steamers, against 28 in 1877. During the year the Howsang and Szechuew were lost, both valuable vessels, and the fleet was reinforced apparently, for we are not given details, by the acquisition of the Soochow, the Hwai-yuen, the Ta-yew, ove of the Foochow gunboats, and the sailing. vessel Cheng-ta. Of these, several had already stood in the Company's books, the Ta-yew at 41,500 taels, while there

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account