Shanghai, 5th Jan, Bofor H. Bartey, Esq., Consul-General,
and iting as Judge, and Mr, 0. Buerant ptain Basserr, Assessors.
Fav-on une v. Cartes A. Sura, Mr. Warsewrtonrappeared for the plaintiff.
Mr. J. J. HEwpessoy appeared for the defendant.
Plaintiff in his petition sot forth that he Chinese subject doing business in Shanghai, and that the defendant is a ci the United States residing within of the Court. On or about 1879, th the for them a larchs according then prepared, and the price was Tls. 4,000, After the contr The plaintiff built larchs according to th fication, except 0 far Geation' was departed from with the kuowand consent of the defendant, who took ry of the lorcha and still retained pos-ma of her. Notwithstanding, fendant had not paid to the whole of the puroli of but was still indebted i came indebted to th of money ov rice amount fendant also fore, sought to ud costs of the ively that she was not ould hay and that only Tls. 279 of plaintiff's account for extras were properly chargeable to the defendant, Defendant denied that he was indebted to the tiff on the cent! or any way whatever, and deducting "Tis, 200 not tai form his contract, the which he asked to be againat the plai To the counter-claim thus defendant's answer to the pi plaintiff pleaded and denied thai
alleged that the lorcha was built in " work-wae baht "negligently "or defective, man-like manner and to the satisfaction of the lant, who superintended the work and at no time made any complaint as to the way in which it was execut Plaintiff denioc that the lorcha was not Guished for fifty days after the contract had expired, and assid that any delay which took place in the completion, and delivery of the vessel was caused by the do-fondant and was agreed to by Ho also denied that any of the items claimed by him as extras were to be furnished by him, or that any of the items were purchased by the de-fant; and he further pleaded that the defendant bad sustained no damage whatever, Mr, Warsewniour called the plaintiff and four or five other witn: who had been engaged in making the lorcha, in support of the statements made in the petition and answer to the counter-claim. T! lence twas to-the effect that the work was sub-let by the plaintiff to another Chinaman named Tout, "who, ste. "Wainewright explained, had disappeared, and two of the witn anid they lind vot seen him for a couple of months. While the lorcha was being built the defendant was constantly at the yard and gave direct to how the work should be done and what wood and other materials should be used. By defendant's rections certain alterations were made in the original plan. the depth of the hold, under the contract, was to be ton ut defendant wanted it a little lower and.
wish was complied with, The bul-worke wer by the ovntract, to be thr ind by the defendant's direc de six inches higher, De. fondant expr imaclf dissatisfied with some of the planks that had beea used and others were substituted, By the orders of the defendant eight inch square-headed nails instead of bolts were used as fastenings in certain parts of the vessel, The lorcha was in course of construction from February to the end of July.
The case ocoupied the whole 4.30 p.m., the proceedings wer next afternoon.
"Tu pursuance of an agreement, dated the 20th day of December, 1879, and made the Chia Morohante' Steam and John The Bonita in jit a flare-up light every fifteen minutes, and did by such omi collision. The proosoded up the river, at too great a speed, did not keep a sufficiently careful look-out, and did not 8 upon the collision oppe ud by such id collision, "2,—That each party jonid pay their that the cos! of the reference lly igned and published, the 10th day of Tanuary, 1880, in the presence of (Gigned) Nrowoxas J. Haxszn.
(Signed) ""Henay Evsras." months from the date of the agreement, robs was not Gnished in manner, nor to but that it was built' so de aged to have much over again, whereby the lorcha was inouré of much less value than she would havi if built according to contract, On this dofoudaut further claimed to be d upon, and that by reason of the lure to perform his agreement. tu this respect defendant had been delayed in hi lores, but pointed out that iff's attention to the defecti: tala cording to agreement, that of the damage occasioned thereby, and that the price of the work would be reduc accordingly. Defendant sise admitted th the plaintiff did certain extra work on ti lorcha, but said th portion pi extras were to be furnished by the plaintiff under agreement, and that other items included in tthe bill wore purchased Ly defendant himself, 6th Jan, The hi ring of this om was resumed at He hed received the particulars from which he had made the entry (then in Court.)
Toxo A-rox recalled, said that he had papers and original entries of his ow: to questions from the Court, th that they were memoranda made by day at 5 p.m. The witness then proceeded to read off the various items of the account which it was alleged had not been included in the contract between plaintiff and def ant one by one, Mr. Wainewright asking quos-jous on each as to why it had been charged for as an extra, and Mr. Henderson making not infrequent objections on one point or another. Thirty of the items having boon gone through in this way, at 4.20 pum. the court adjourned till next day.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.