Ox a former occasion, speaking of the Commission appointed for the purpose of investigating the position and management of the Consular Service, we noticed the stand made by our present Consul, Mr. Medhurst, against the unpopular, and, at least, questionably legal tax denominated the Registration Fee, Judging from the interval of exemption which we enjoyed last year, it seemed natural to suppose that this miserable device, which could not fail to create unpleasantness between the Foreign Office and the British residents in China, had been quietly allowed to sink into oblivion; and that its utter uselessness, compared with its offensive nature, had at last been discovered at head-quarters. In this hope, however, we find ourselves disappointed; the Foreign Office, to all appearances, is determined to keep open an old unpleasantness, and the Consul is made the medium of endeavouring to persuade the British subjects under his care, that in keeping aloof from an ordinance known to be useless, and more than believed to be illegal, they are really the injuring party. Now, it will be well to state plainly, once and for all, that this objection to pay the Registration Fee does not proceed from any deep-seated aversion to innet the legitimate calls of the British Gorernanent on the resident community; but a tax levied illegally, and in a place where machinery exists for reducing Imperial expenditure by perfectly legitimate measures, cannot but excite suspicion and it is this suspicion which really lies at the bottom of the opposition. Why should the British' Government set itself to judge between its subjects as to who is to pay five dollars, or from whom it is contented tomake one? We confess ourselves utterly unable to discover iti what function, or by what law or precedent, a paternal government is to step in.and constitute itself judge of our social position. It is only another instance. of official meddling: and meddling and muddling differ but in a slight degree from one another. In fact it is but'a development of the idea that those dependencies which have not the power to direct their own policy shall be continually threatened and bullied by the Home Secretaries; but that those who have attained to the rank of large or troublesome communi: ties shall bave, in turn, the right of bullying passed over to them.- The British communities in China owe a great deal to the British Government, and are quite willing to make the acknowledgement. At the same time Great Britain herself owes a good deal to the energy of the China communities, and we would like to see the acknowledgement made with equal grace. We certainly are children of too large a growth to willingly submit to be placed in leading strings, and as the advantages of our relative positions are mutual, we dislike to be lectured on the sentimental duties we are supposed to owe to Her Majesty's Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs. Altogether beyond the sentimental view is the legal one, and here we cannot but ask how even the inge-unity of a law officer could twist the permission to make regulations for the governance of British subjects into an authority to levy a discriminating tax In fact the matter raises the whole question of the the status of the Order in Councilitself. Orders in Council, we opine, are to be classed with other documents issuing directly from the Crown, that is to say, they are effective so far as they are legal, but. they can in no case take the place of law or become its substitute. What is known asa Royal Proclamation stands on the same footing. The Crown undertakes the responsibility of issuing these under certain exceptional conditions, and so far as its conduct in respect thereof is consonant with law, its actions are perfectly legal. No judge, however, could be bound to look upon the Proclamation as the law itself. Ca the contrary he has, as it were, to judge of its legality in every case, and®should it be found wanting in this important element it must be declared in. effective. Now the Order in Council isa similar case. So far as it enables the Crown to make regulations for the due governance of its subjects, and so far as it legally applies these rules, so far is it legally and morally binding, It is not, however, to be left to the caprice of Her Majesty's legal advisors for the time being to make definite laws for the restraint of her subjects, New crimes cannot be constituted by a stroke of the pen of a Secretary of State of which the law of England has no cognisance; and it is because the laws of England lend no sanction to any such attempt as irresponsible taxa tion that we call in question the clauses in the Order in Council relating thereto. It is interesting, however, as showing the tenacity with which the official mind clings to ideas of the sort, to recall that in the very first
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.