The Archive · 1880

Glimpses at Foreign Reviews

Of all German metaphysicians, Schopenhauer is perhaps the one most generally read by people of ordinary cultivation. Miss Zimmern's excellent book on his life and philosophy has placed his speculations within everybody's reach. This recognition has been tardy, for his profound contempt for his contemporaries and predecessors was repaid by the former in the shape of silent neglect. His fundamental propositions are that the organic life manifested in Nature and all her departments under the form of will is the only reality in the universe of things, and that it is the subjective presentation of this organic life which constitutes the intelligence, Schopenhauer himself in many parts of his writings acknowledges that his system is based on the researches, discoveries and speculations of Cabanis and Bichat, M. Paul Janet in the Revue des Dew Mendes (Ist May) discusses the extent of the obligations due by the German philosopher to the French physiologists, and succeeds in setting forth the almost forgotten claims of these two eminent men to the honour of anticipating the scientific opinions of the present day. The work that they did can never be undone. They proved that real Imowledge of the mind's mode of action can be gained only at the expense of a minute investigation of the nervous system in animals and man. And that undernatural conditions, not under such speculative conditions as those laid down by Condillae in his theoretical investigation of the mental development of a statue to which one avenue of knowledge after another should be opened, Ina word, they extended the purely experimental method to the investigation of mental phenomena. Among these mental phenomena, or underlying them all, they recognised the organic presentation, that is, the inconscient influence exerted by every bodily organ upon the brain, In this consists individual vitality, on this is moulded character, from this are developed the emotions which through the medium of the will are translated into actions. This internal sensibility declaring itself in emotion and will had escaped the attention of all the eighteenth century philosophers. Like external sensation it could be due only to small motions, or as we should now call them, molecular vibrations, and these are started by conditions of the internal organs. With some modi! cations this doctrine is accepted at the present day, and its acceptance is in great measure due to Schopenhauer, who after frankly accepting and acknowledging the results of anatomical and physiological investigations in which he could not take part, popularized while amplifying the views of his French contemporaries. Condensed to the utmost, these views amounted to this, that what subjectively the individual is conscious of as intellect is objectively simply brain, and what subjectively is willis objectively the totality of the organism.

—Those who have read Bosworth Smith's Carthage and the Carthaginians will not find much that is now in M. Albert Reville's La Passage @ Hannibal travers La Gate et les Alpes, This achievement, than which history can shew none greater, has given rise to a larger number of controversies than even the great Homeric question. We know that in the spring of 218 B.C., Hannibal started from Carthagena ninety thousand infantry, twelve thousand cavalry and a large number of elephants, that he crossed the Pyrenees, advanced through the southern part of Gaul, crossed the Rhone, ascended the Alps, and descended on the Italian side of the range. We are informed that he left ten thousand infantry with a thousand cavalry to garrison Catalonia, sent twelve thousand faint-hearted back, lost about four thousand in his opening campaign, and turned a whole army corps into sailors. All deductions made, he crossed the Pyrenees with fifty thousand infantry and nine thousand cavalry. But where did he cross? Nobody knows, There is not a defile in the Pyrenees for which the honour is not claimed. He reached Gaul at all events, and marched to the Rhone. But along what route?

Nobody knows that either. Probably along the old Ligurian road, which when subsequently improved by the Romans, was known as the Via Domitia, Arrived at the Rhone, with forces thinned to forty-si thousand men of all arms, he crossed it.

But hardly any two historians agree as to the place he selected. Having renewed his stores and military equipment he engaged his army in the defiles of the Alps, and here again not less than seven inet routes are proposed, and supported by masses of erudition so nicely balanced as to leave all but special military experts in a condition of absolute doubt as to the one really adopted. Every schoolboy has read the story of the passage across the Alps with its apparently insurmountable difficulties. Amongst these difficulties the vinegar episode is the only one which lends a fabulous air to the tale. Dacier suggested that when it became necessary to cut through the solid rock, Hannibal distributed large rations of sour wine to his troops in order to lend strength to their arms. Commandant Hennebert, the latest writer onthe subject, imagines that the Carthaginians were in possession of some explosive compound resembling dynamite or nitro-glycerine which they called vinegar, and wherewith they blasted the rock. No fancy could well be more absurd. The most reasonable explanation is that offered by M. Maissiat, who sees in the word acetum, used by Livy, a vulgar or accidental form of centum, which signified a pickaxes. The confusion once made, the legend would have easily taken shape. When finally, after five months' constant marching, Hannibal reached the plains of the Po, his army was reduced to twenty-six thousand men, the survivors of battle, evid, sickness, accident and desertion.—The exertions successfully made during the past few exterminate the Indians of the Pampas are set forth in a graphic paper by M. Ebélot, who is, or has lately been, an officer in the Argentine service. The Indian tribes have doubtless been a scourge to the civilized settlements, and their subjugation had become a necessity. Accordingly, they have been treated exactly as wild beasts, the process being described with cynical composure by the author of the paper before us.—The by-ways of history have a great charm for most people, and this is all the more keenly felt when the persons whose deeds or misdeeds are brought to light occupy already a large place on the historical stage. The domestic relations of Peter the Great were anything rather than happy. He was early estranged from his first wile, Eudoxie Lapouchine, and from his sisters, who were implicated in the plots laid ayainst him by the reactionary party among the nobility. His son Alexis, whose intellect was besotted by drunkenness and superstition, offered a tacit opposition to all his plans, and gave ample proof that when his turn came to reign the old Oriental system of life and government would resume sway in Russia, Forced to provide for the succession, and determined that his work should not perish with him, Peter made continually repeated attempts to withdraw the Crown Prince from the priestly influences by which he was surrounded. He expected great things from a suitable marring, and after much opposition from the prince, he succeeded in linking him to a princess of the House of Brunswick, Her miseries were after a brief period terminated by death, but she left a son to whom in case of need the crown might pass. This consideration and the fact that Catherine had given birth to a son gave point to Peter's remonstrances, Brought face to face with his difficulties, on the one hand his own temperament, tastes and prejudices, on the other his father's fixed determination that his successor should carry on the system that he had inaugurated, Alexis determined to give up the struggle and formally to abandon his claim to the crown, Peter, however, knew well that at the proper moment Alexis would be brought from the depths of whatever monastery might be sheltering him and placed on the throne by the combined influence of all the clergy, in spite of his formal renunciation, It became clear that one of two things must happen, either Alexis must conform to his father's spirit, or must disappear under his father's anger. There was, it is true, o third solution of the difficulty, but one most unnatural to such a prince as Alexis, whose thoughts were limited by the harem, the Cathedral and the banquet-room. He might fly, and after much persuasion and discussion, fly he did. The chase opened after him across Europe, the ingenuity displayed by the Emperor Charles VI in concealing him as a prisoner of State, the equal ingenuity of the spies set to watch at every court, the demand for his release, his escape and renewed flight until at length he found refuge at Naples, are told with great dramatic skill, At Naples the story leaves him. Thence we know ho years by the Argentine Republic to was finally dragged to Moscow, where, after

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account