The Archive · 1880

Machine Guns Versus Torpedo Boats

To the Editor of the Srm,—Since the adoption of steel in the manufacture of torpedo boats, and since the very rapid advance that has been of late yeats effected in that mode of naval offend sive warfare, it has been necessary to devise some means by which such an attack can be best repelled.

Nets, booms or spars, and combinations of these termed crinolines, have been from time to time proposed and employed as repellants, but such modes of defence must always considerably detract from the actual efficiency of a man-of-war, by more or less reducing her speed and power of rapidly shifting position, and it has also been proved in actual war that such defences can be jumped by fast torpedo boats. To put such obstacles on one side, vessel of war has hitherto only had her heavy guns, her light or boat guns, her small calibre Gatlings, and her rifles to defend herself with against the attack of torpedo boats, and the lesson learnt from the late Russo-Turkish war proves that with such weapons only to depend on she is entirely at the mercy of a bold and determined attack of her pigmy assailants. 21 knots per hour,* Peel be capable of which may possess a speed of from 16 to A Yarrow or Thornicroft torpedo boat,

rushing the last 500 yards of her onslaught in from 56 to 43 seconds; and would probably not be detected on a dark night, or in misty or foggy weather even by the aid of the electric light, until a considerably closer distance had been attained; therefore torepel, thatis to sink, or completely disable, the attacking torpedo boat, some very rapid firing gun, throwing a bullet of sufficient size, weight, and velocity to easily pene-the sides of a steel boat, and at the same time to make a large jagged hole, was necessary.

This want has now been most successfully supplied by the Nordenfelt four barrel machine gu, of 1 inch calibre, and throwing a solid steel shot of 4-1b. weight.

The only other gun of a similar nature that up to the present time has appeared is the Hotchkiss five barrel revolving cannon of 1}-inch calibre, and throwing a steel bullet, or shell of about 1-Ib. weight.

discussion and difference of opinion in For some time past there has been great naval circles of all countries, as to which of the foregoing systems of machine guns la the best, viz., the Hotchkiss, firing slowly and using shell, or the Nordenfelt, firing rapidly and using solid shot, finally decide the merits and practical capabilities of these two machine guns, a ies of most exhaustive trials has recently been carried out at Portsmouth under the supervision of the officers of H.M. gunnery ship Excellent, a digest of which is herewith give Trials between the Nordenfelt 1-inch gun, and the Hotchkiss 1}-inch gun, carried vut at sea off Portsmouth on 13th May 1880 The guns were mounted on the forecastle of H.M. gunboat Medway, and were fired against models of torpedo boats moored at sea:—two models for each gun.

Two guns' crews of H.M.S. Bvcelleut had been trained for several weeks to serve Doth the guns, and these crews were changed regularly from one gun to the other, so that no difference in individual smartness should interfere with the comparative results, The speed of the Mediay against the current, and against a slight N.E, wind averaged only about seven knots.

(a) In the first and second runs the Mediay started at 1,500 yards distance, and ran close up to the torpedo boat.

One of the English torpalo boats built by Messr. Yarrow and Ca, attained a speed of 2193 note at Ler Each gun fired at right angles against the side of the torpedo boat.

In the third and fourth runs, the Medway started at about 1,500 yards distance, and ran up to about 150 yards from the torpedo boat.

In the fifth and sixth runs, the guns fired end on ina line with the keel of the torpedo boat, so that only their bows were visible.

(e) In the seventh and eighth runs, the Aedicay started at about 500 yards distance, and ran close up to the torpedo boat.

The following table shows the results 23

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account