The Archive · 1880

EXTRA-TERRITORIALITY

Warte so much of the world as can takes holiday in the European summer, there is a largo portion that devotes its time to self-improvement, For them the various congresses hold. their annual assemblies; some go to anti-quar ian meetings, where in fine weather old churches are described, and flirting and lanching divide the time with the reading of papers on antiquities as veracious so that described in the early pages of Pickwick. -Trae votaries of science flock to the meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, and hear and discuss papers in every branch of philosophy. The reformers of all things beman meet together in n Social Science Congress, where nothing that affects humanity is too small or too majestic for the touch of those who would put the world in lending.strings, could they only find heed fal and teachable generation, Among the most valuable of these assemblies is the annual sitting of the International Law Association, which is attended by jurists of all nations, anxious to assimilate as far as possible the Inws and customs of civilised peoples, and we propose to-day to draw attention to two of the papers read at the late sitting, which was held this year at Berne.

The papers were on the subject of extra-territoriality, or the right of foreign residents in uncivilized countries to be amenable only to their own authorities. In the Tarkish possessions in the Levant under what are known as the capitulations, the extra-territoriality, uow subsisting in China and Japan, has long been established; and it was on "The Consular Jurisdiction in the Levant" that Sir Travers Twiss read the former paper. He showed that this dated from the ninth century, at which time, under the Caliph Haroun al Raschid, the starting-point in this jurisdiction may be assumed to have taken place. These privileges have been confirmed at successive intervals down to the present day, their chief cause being the impossibility of intermixing Christian and Mahomedan races. Modern doctrinaires are supposed to be only too anxious to give up these privileges, heedless of the danger to which their nationals are exposed, or rather with the feeling that man who elects to exile himself to a barbarous nation must there take his chance; but so eminent an authority io international law as Sir Travers Twiss came to the'conclasion that in a country where the evidence of a Christian is of no validity, if contradicted by that of a Mahomedan, it would be undesirable to abolish or restrict the jurisdiction of our Consular Courts, China, which comes next to Turkey in feeling the irksomeness of extraterritoriality, seems not to have been represented at the Conference, but the question was taken up on behalf of Japan by Mr. Iriyé, a Japanese, but a member of the Middle Temple, London. Ho naturally objected to the way in which his own country is treated. He argued that the origin of the concession granted to foreigners, the great progress made in his country, the absence of all fanaticism, the power of the Central Government, which was felt throughout the whole Empire, and other considerations, pointed to distinct characteristics in Consular jurisdiction in Japan, His contention was that the treaties which gave foreign Powers the right to try their own citizens, laid on them also the duty of punishing them and he complained that while Japan bad filled her part of the bargain, foreign Powers lad not been equally honest. The Consular judges are many of them palpably incompetent; in cases involving different nationalities, no power exists in the Court of one nation to procure evidence from the subjects of a different. nation; and a Japanese, who is plaintiff in. a Consular Court and loses his suit, has to appeal to a higher Court on the other side of the world. Moreover, some Consuls so far strain the treaties as to hold that their nationals are outside the operation of all Japanese laws, criminal, administra. tive or municipal, and allow them to set at defiance, to the injury of the Japanese Government, such purely administrative measures as game laws and quarantine regulations. Ho was of opinion that Japan had proved herself sufficiently advanced in modern ways to be allowed jurisdiction over all residents on her soil whatever their nationality; or that

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account