Wo have been requested to publish the following letter which has been addressed by the Committee of the Chamber of commerce to the Tea Guild Shanghai, 17th December, 1880.
Genrizxen,—{ have the honour to acknowledge your communication of the 28rd October on the subject of* certain customs in the tea trade, It was at once laid before the Committee of the Chamber, and I am to express to you their gratification, that you should have sought this method of discussing questions which affect alike the interests of Chinese and foreign merchants. It has been our aim to meet you in this matter sith the utmost frank-nos The Committee had no objection to offer to several of your proposals, which are in conformity with the g custom of the trade. At the same time they were of decided opinion that no action on their part would lead to any good result, wu less general revision of the conditions of ten contracts could be made to the mutual satisfaction of buyers and sellers. With this view they named a sub-Committee to confer with delegates from your body, to ascertain whether a common understanding was likely to be reached, before submitting the matter to a general meeting of the Chamber.
Our sub-Committee lost no time in consulting with as many tea buyers as possible, so that, at their first interview with your delegates, they were able to apeak with some confidence of the feelings of foreign merchants. I may briefly recapitulate what the Committee believe to be the general opinion on the principal points at issue.
The "cutting of weights" to which you draw attention, more however with reference to Hankow than to Shanghai, is distinctly deprecated, but while there is no sympathy with the few foreigners who are addicted to the practice, there is very little with the many Chinese tea brokers who have allowed it to continue and grow without applying the remedy which has been in their own hands: more than this, the records of the market show that teas have deen habitually sold to the few firms who are known to "cut weights," at exactly the same prices as to the great majority of foreign merchants who weigh proper! Thus the very custom of which you complain has been enconrayed by yourselves, to the manifest detriment of every foreign buyer who has dealt fairly with you.
It is well known that the system of cutting" originated in an attempt to secure such weights in China as would bring out the London weight without loss after deduction of the pound draft allowed there. It now appears that the persons who were first permitted to "cut" by the teamen have been led by their early success to increase their deductions from the scale weight, until, as the Committee are informed, there are instances where the London out-turn has been three to four per cent. more than the invoice weight.
Tt was in apprehension of some such result as this that the Committee of the Chamber, at the instance of the foreign tea merchants, forwarded to you on the 12th April 1878, a request that the pound draft should be allowed here, in order to assimilate the custom of Shanghai with that long established in the t tea market of the world. This had already been done elsewhere in China without inconvenience, and your refusal to accept the suggestion was received with the more regret as the reasons given by you were hardly deemed satisfactory by the foreign community.
The Committee hoped that the dimensions which the abuse had assumed during the past few years might cause you to reconsider your decision, They had reason to believe that, if the pound draft were allowed here, arrangements could be made which would prevent "cutting" in the future by providing an easy mode of settling all disputes as to weights. Unless, how-exer, this concession were made by the teamen, the Committee were satisfied that the Chamber would prefer to let matters take their course until such time as the evil should work its own cure, The Committee accordingly formulated the following draft of conditions of tea contracts, which they were prepared to ask the Chamber to declare as the custom of the port, in all cases where special agreoments had not boon made between buyer and seller.
1,—All tea to be weighed by " standard 2.—Fractions of a pound to be in favour of the buyer, and one pound draft to be allowed on every package weighing 28lbs. gross or more.
3.—Should the buyer and seller be unable to agree as tothe weight of the tea, the chop to be re-weighed by the Secretary of the Chamber of Commerce, and his weight shall be accepted as final.' A reasonable fee to be paid the Secretary for such work by the party at fault.
4,—All tea to be weighed within three weeks at the outside from the time of si ing the contract book.
5.—Payment to be made not later than on the day following the weighing of the tea.
6.—All tea to be at the buyer's risk and to be fully covered by fire or marine insurance at the buyer's expense, from the time the buyer has requested or sanctioned its being brought into godown until paid for to the seller.
7.—In case of false packing the certificate of broker and dock superintendent at destination to be sufficient proof upon which to recover from the teaman, and the Guild to use its influence to enable the buyer to recover under such proof, 8,—The Committee of the Chamber will be prepared to appoint a sub-Committee to arbitrate on all differences arising between buyers and sellers of tea (other than questions of weight) in conjunction with a sub-Committee appointed by the Guild. Each special case referred fur settlement to be dealt with by one member of each sub-Committee, selected by his colleagues, with power to call in an umpire.
These were presented by our sub-Committee at their first interview with your delegates, who, after a long and friendly discussion, promised to lay them before your body'and to report your views thereon as soo as possible. At the second meet ing, our representatives were informed that you were unable to accede to the allowance of the pound draft, and to other points of minor importance.
The Committee are disappointed to find that the correspondence and discussion between us have not brought us any nearer to an understanding, and I am to inform you that, under the circumstances, they see no advantage in calling the Chamber together to consider the rules proposed in your letter of 23rd October. But, as I have already remarked, the system pursued daring the pest season lins been a2 imanifestly unjust to the great majority of foreigners in the trade, that it can hardly continue, and individual buyers must be left to find the remedy for themselves.
Tam, Gentlemen, Your obedient servant, (Signed) F. B. Fornxs, Chairman, To tux Members or THE Suancuar Tza Guy, THE OPENING OF ST. LUKR'S HOSPITAL,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.