The Archive · 1882

Purchase of Land in the Interior

Tuxnp ie a question continually oropping up in one shape, or another which bids fair to assume formidable proportions ere very long. We refer to the right of missionaries to purchase land in the interior. We are not speaking now of the moral question as to whether a missionary is justified in speculating on: his own account. Of this practice there have been many instances: in the history of missionary relations with China, and some nature the reverse of creditable to the operators and their cause. The subject we uow allude to is one of Treaty rights and Treaty interpretation, and in view of recent events it is highly desirable that some distinct under. standing should be arrived at. The missionaries at Chi-nan Fa have been suffering greatly through the tarbulence of @ mob and the subsequent obstruction of the mandant the matter of laud-purchase. A similar complaint reaches us from Lien-chou, on the same score. It was in connection with the purchase of land that the Abbé Conraux was tortured and half-killed by a mob of pratal soldiery at the in jou of their officers. The purchase of land has been at the root of three-fourths of the difficulties under which missionaries have laboured in the interior, and given no doubt a proportionate amon of trouble and annoyance to the Ministers. Now, bow does the matter stand? Legally or illegally, missionaries reside in the interior, and build houses, and chapels, and schools. This alves the purchase of ground, and again, @ good deal of negotiation with the local authorities. It is remarkable, however, that the authorities in no case openly dispute the right of missionaries to buy. They simply put all the abstractions possible in their way, deluding them with false promises, punishing the vendors of land' in secret, and doing all in their power to nullify if not prevent traneactions. This is a state of things which cannot and should not continue. If missionaries have a right to buy land in the provinces, let that right be recognined and enforced, and all attempts to evade compliance banished. Bat have they? Here again we are hampered by the vague and unsatisfactory wording of the Treaty. If Articles IX and XIE of the Treaty of Tientsin be taken together, the result seems certainly such as to justify an affirmative answer. British subjects are thereby empowered to purchase ground and build houses not only at the open ports but also "at other places." A plain man reading this would interpret it in the widest manner, as meaning "any" other places; and, taken its context " the open ports," it might fairly be held to mean the interior of the country. But now Sir Thomas Wade steps in and forbids any euch interpretation. These words, ho says, are held by a large proportion of British subjects to concede them the right to establish themselves in the interior just as they do at the ports; but they Lave been misunderstood, The word "ports" means, as far as we understand the Minister's explanation, the cities in the neighbourhood of which foreign trade is established, and the "other places" are simply the foreign settlements, If any of our readers think this interpretation an erroneous one, let them refer to the N.-O. Herald of the 220d November, 1881, where article is published embodying Sir Thomas Wade's own words. The tory of the much.disputed clause is there given at length, and the circamstances of its insertion very fully explained. As regards the British Treaty, then, we have no right to purchase Ind in the interior. The United States Treaties ignore the privilege still more effectually. Article XII of the Treaty, ratifications of which were exchanged at Pei-tang in 1859, simply empowers U.S. citizens residing or sojourning at any of the ports open to commerce to refit houses ete., and to hire sites for chapels, cemeteries, and hospitals, Nota word is said of any right even to travel in the interior, It' was not till ten years afterwards that the right of United States citizens to travel was formally recog: nised; and then only on the distinct understanding that the United States did not interfere with the domestic administration of the Empire in regard to material internal improvements. It seems then that we have to fall back upon the Favoured Nation clause in its application to the Troaties with Bata study of the French Treaties will show that the citizens of the République are very little better off than ourselves. There is no article which clearly and actually acknowledges the right of a Frenchman to live and become the proprietor of land in the interior of China, He is por-mitted to "go to"—so render d—cities not open to trade, under passport bat all the privileges and immunity of residence are limited to the open ports. It is desirable, therefore, that this plain fact should be fully understood by missionaries. They have no right to purchase land in the interior of China; or, if they have, it is ao obscurely set forth in their treaties as to be of very little practical value. Nor have they any distinctly defined right even to live there, That they do acquire property and live in the interior is an undeniable fact, but it is so only on account of a very elastic interpretation of the Treaty in their favour. Possession, however, is nine tenths of the law; and we should therefore urge that their right to do what they are now doing really without Treaty provisions should be formally recognised, Their position at present is a false one, and the sooner it is placed ona more satisfactory footing the better for all concerned. There is perhaps at the moment no method in which the Hon, Russell Young could render more solid service to his nationals and other foreigners in Ohina than by setting this most fertile source of irritation at rest; and by so doing he would earn the heartfelt thanks of all classes, missionaries and merchants alike.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account