Before Sir R. T. Rey Tustice, HD's Chief Vox Drevscue v, Hoxexoxe & Siaxcuat This was a suit brought by Mr. von Dreusche ayainst the Hongkong and Shanghai Bank, to recover a sum of 'Tls. 9,367.68, being the amount of loss sustained' by the alleged wrongful action of the bank in removing the plaintifis goods.
From the pleadings in this case it appeared that in the winter of 1885 and spring of 1886, the plaintiff overdraw his account at the bank, and, as security against such overdraft, signed promissory notes, and, further, gave the bank letters of hypothecation on certain goods then stored in his godowns. Shortly afterwards the bank took possession of the goods so pledged, and removed them from the plaintiff's control into other godowns, and the present suit was brought to recover the sum which
action of the ban! the plaintiff alleged he had lost by the and, on the Court pi ing to settle The facts in the case were not disputed,.
issues, it was settled that the first question to be decided was whether the bank's action was legal or not, the question as to recovery for loss sustained depending entirely on the decision which might be arrived at on the first fiske.
The plaintiff, on being sworn, recapitulated the facts as given above, and argued that the bank's action was illegal because they had seized his goods without previously demanding payment of the amount due by him. He denied that his goods had ever Deen attached by the German Consular Court, alleging that the action of the then Acting German Consul had been ultra vires and illegal. The promissory notes given to the bank had never been presented for payment, and he contended that the letters of hypothecation which he had signed intended solely as supplementary security to the promissory notes, and could only be acted on after failure on his part to pay these. Such failure not having taken place at the time of seizure he contended that the seizure had been illegal, and therefore sued for the loss caused by his inability to dispose of the cargo consequent on its removal from his own custody, Mr. Leith, agent of the defendants, deposed that in the spring of 1886, hearing that the plaintiff's goods were attached by order of the German Consular Court, he produced the plaintiff's letters of hypothecation to the then Acting German Consul, and applied for the release of the goods. 'This was granted, and the defendants thereupon removed' the goods from the plaintiff's custody. This course was necessary for the protection of the bank's interest in the goods. and was, he contend-el, warranted by the terms of the letters of hypothecation signed by the plaintiff.
His Lordship here intimated to. the plaintiff that he was clearly of opinion that the defendants had not exceeded their legal rights in the removal of the goods, and pointed out that if the plaintiff desired a decree for an account to be taken of the dealings between himself and the defendants, he would be allowed so to amend his petition as to entitle him to such relief.
The plaintiff declining to avail himself of this offer, His Lordship gave judgment for the defendants, dismissing the petition with costs.
Rirrer v. Jarprse, Matazsoy & Ca.
The plaintiff in this ease sues for the value of a cask of claret shipped from Bordeaux by the Messayeries Maritimes and forwarded from Shanghai by one of the defendant Company's steamers, The cask on arrival in Shanghai had been found to be leaking, and on reaching Tientsin was empty. The defendant Company, before taking delivery in Shanghai, had tried to recover the value from the M.M. Ca. but they, relying on a clause in their Bil of Lading exempting them from liability in cases of leakage, refused to acknowledge any responsibility. On the arrival of the cask in Tientsin the plaintiff refused to take delivery, and sought to recover the value from the defendants. The latter denied their liability, pleading that they received the cask in a leaky condition, and were not linble for damage which occurred previously to its coming into their hands.
The facts were not disputed. His Lordship in giving judgment, after reciting the facts as given above, said: "The defendants, having received the cask in a leaky condition, and partially emptied, it would certainly be wholly contrary to reason to make them pay for the whole of the wine lost. If, however, they were to be charged with a portion of the loss, how would it be possible to estimate the amount of such loss? The cask may when re-shipped from Shanghai, have been three-quarters full or only one quarter, or less. The plaintiff may have his remedy, either against the insurers, if the wine was in fact insured, or, if not, perhaps against the shippers for having used a defective case; but I cannot go Beyond the primary cause of the damage, or hold the defendenta lable for damage which, in a question like this, appears to have resulted from a primary cause. The petition must therefore be dismissed with costs,—Chinese Times,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.