The Archive · 1891

THE AMALGAMATION OF THE CHIEF-JUDGE AND CONSUL- GENERAL

16th March.

Ir is confidently stated that the amal-motion of the functions of Chief-budge and Consul-General at Shanghai is due to the malignant activity of Sir Thomas Wade who, we are told, is still regarded at the Foreign Office as a reliable authority on China matters. As long as he was at Peking, he was our dete noire: he was the classical instance of the men whom a familiar acquaintance with the Chinese language and literature makes more Chinese than the Chinese themselves. When he retired from active service and sank gracefully into the lettered ease of a professorship at Cambridge, we flattered ourselves that his dangerous participation in the relations between England and China was removed; but there is reason to fear that he still comes out of his retirement from time to time to exercise a maleficent influence on the counsels of the Chinese department at the Foreign Office; and when we remember how strenuously he repressed when he was Minister ever consular official who ventured to out of the policy of self-effacement before the Chinese which he inculcated, has helped to induce the retrograde it seems quite credible that his advice

step that has now been taken. Sir Thomas Wade heartily detested Mr. Alabaster because he held his. own against the Chinese, and must be delighted by, if he did not arrange, the alteration which finally deprives Mr. Alabaster of the merited goal of his ambition, the consul-generalship at Shanghai. 'To Sir 'Thomas Wade we owe it, we are told, that Mr. Davenport did not return to China in a much higher joxition: It is certain that in the case of it Thomas "the evil that men do lives after them." We do' not know enough yet to say defini itis to Sir Thomas Wade that. we owe this' grave mistake, but it is at any rate the sort of thing that he would have recommended. Another theory is that it is; the outcome of the unaided genius of Sir Philip Currie, who has always been a persona grata with the Marquis of Salisbury, whose priate seoretary he was when the Marquis was Foreign Secretary in the Earl of Beaconsfield's last government. The desire for economy is supposed to have prompted; the change, the necessity of finding source from which the salaries of the consular staff in Corea might be drawn, without making a fresh call on the British taxpayer. If Corea, however, is worth a consular establishment at all, the cost should surely be provided openly; and we smile grimly at the economy from which we suffer, when we notice contemporaneously the aunouncement that pensions have just been granted to two Ministers who are not precisely paupers, Viscount Cross and Sir Michael Hicks-Beach. If the China Association is not merely an in-; stitution for arranging an annual dinner of old China hands, it is to be hoped that it will vigorously take up our remonstrances and push them home. Unfortunately, there is a good deal of jealousy on the pert of the diplomatic branch against the consular branch of the Queen's service in China, a jealousy that shows itself in the expressed determination of the Foreign Office never to appoint another Minister to Peking from the consular ranks; and so we get as the Queen's representative a courteous old geutlemav, who has spent the best part of his life ranging delicate questions of etiquette at ami ional balls and banquets in a European capital, and whose native firmness of character has been so sapped, that he will protest to a the last moment both verbally and in writing against being received in an unworthy audience chamber, and then give way. It is true that the other Ministers protested' with him, and equally gave way; but we look to see the British Minister upholding the dignity of his country, however weak-kneed his colleagues may be. Unfortunately a Sir Harry Parkes is a rara avis; and Sir Harry came from the consular ranks. system against which the meeting of In commenting on the ¢ of

Tuesday last was called to protest, we have dwelt rather on the mischief done to the consular side of the question the Chinese Times in its editorial of the 7th instant dwells more on the mischief that will be done to the judicial side. It points out what an excellent effect the existence at Shanghai of a court of justice, "freed from political considerations, from the bias of official interests, from corruption, and the pressure of public opinion," has had on the Chinese and on all the consular courts, not only the British,'in China. The decision which condemned the P. & 0. Company to pay heavy damages. in. the case of the collision between the Nepaul and the Wan-nien-ching was received by the higher Chinese officials with sheer astonishment as well as admiration. "That a British Court should deliberately condemn a powerful English Corporation to pay heavy damages to an alien was a conception wholly new to the Chinese, and the proof of it raised the character of British justice and the credit of the British name immeasurably in their estimation." Equally valuable has the existence of a Supreme. Court raised above the political and social influences, from which a consul cannot wholly detach himself, been to the British, and indirectly to all foreign residents in China. We have not dwelt so much on this side of the question because this is not, we believe, the side that will chiefly suffer. Mr. Hannen may be trusted to maintain the high level at which his aiaerpegat have maintained the Court; ut if he and his successors are to preserve the necessary detachment from the turmoil and disputation of our everyday life, the consular side must suffer. Much as Peking may dislike the consul-general jhere undertaking diplomatic: business with the local officials, it is inevitable that he should do it. As the rotest adopted on Tuesday, which we hope every British subject here will hurry to sign, points out; "As Her Majesty's Legation is practically inaccessible in cases of emergency, on account of its distance frou Shanghai, the consul-general is our only resort, and hitherto he has by negotiation, obtained for British subjects protection and recognition of just claims, which must practically have been abandoned but for the existence of this mode of procedure." Ihe Foreign Office at home forgets that China is not centralized like european country: that provincial officials settle their own diplomatic questions except in specially momentous cases; and that the foreign consuls therefore have diplomatic duties thrown upon them here from which they are free in more centralized countries. Vestigia nullo retrorsum should be a guiding principle in dealing with China: the Foreign Office has stepped blindly backwards into the condition that, existed here before 1865.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account