The Archive · 1891

The French Mail Papers

Tue last week in October was certainly of the dullest on record, for the papers are chiefly taken up with the speeches of various politicians, who are beginning, work earnestly with a view to the con general elect and we have columns xbout the philo phic Mr. Balfour at Accrington, the p hic Mr, Morley at Manchester, rous Mr, Chim berlain at Sunderland, No one of the Liberals whom dislike of Home Rule for Ireland sent over to the Tories is more hated by those whom he deserted vhxn Mr. Chamberlain, tie is altogether tuo candid; but while it is no doubt true that Lord Salisbury's Cabinet has carried on the government of the country much better than Mr, Gladstone's Cabinet of tive years before did, considering that Mr, Chanberlain was a prominent member of the Intter Cabinet, and was never tired then of glorifying Mr. Glads former colleagues may be excused if they are a little annoyed with him now, and think that his present praise of Lord Salisbury and abuse of Mr. Gladetone come with a somewhat bad grace, The Daily News says Mr. Morley deprecated the spirit of political bitterness, which certainly cannot be imputed to. Itis no doubt a mistake to answer even Mr. Chamberlain in Mr. Chamberlain's own tone and style. But treachery, in public as in private life, excites the righteous anger of honest men, and we rejoice to know that not a single Tory with any knowledge of political history or principles has been found to defend Mr. Chamberlain's denunciation of a Government to which he himself belonged. We do agree with some ardent Liberals who think that Mr. Chamberlain can safel ignored. His great Parliamentary and administrative capacity must always make hima formidable opponent, and he is the only Dissentient Liberal who ever says anything new. But there is a quality in human statements even more important than novelty, and that is truth. Mr. Chamberlain's allegation that most social reforms have come from the Conservatives is almost too wild for comment. Manchester is a place where Lord Hartington still has followers, and Mr. Morley was not wasting time when he reminded them that almost every assertion made by Lord Hartington's chief lieutenant at Sunderland was not only at serious variance, but in violent contrast with previous utterances of Mr. Chamberlain's own. Mr. Morley gi instances, which we need not recapitulate. But we may ask what confidence can be felt in a man who, because he disagrees with Mr. Gladstone's Irish policy, repudiates all his own former convictions and outstrips Mr. Chaplin and Mr. Lowther in the fervour of his neo-Toryism?

Mr. Chamberlain defends himself as follows ina letter to the Times My object in writing is not to complain of Mr. Morley's shrill invective, but to protest, against the new doctrine of Cabinet respon sibility which he has laid down. In plai words, Mr. Morley's contention is that a member of a Cabinet must never admit, even of that Cabinet, or any result of those pr inference, that any one of the proceedings ceedings. may be matter for subsequent eriticism, objection, or regret.

In my address at Sunderland I was speaking of the future when I predicted that Mr, Gladstone, if he returned to power, would take an awful mess of our affairs, and I dwelt on his recent utterances in regard to Egypt and the Triple Alliance as the special justification of my fears. It is true that I said that during the last five years we had had no wars, no costly expeditions, and no votes of credit, and no doubt my hearers were likely to con: trast this state of things—as I did myself most regretfully—with the experience of the five years that preceded. Mr. Morley says that I was jointly responsible for the less satisfactory conditions of the earlier period. T have never denied this, nor have I ever attempted to apportion the responsibility among the individual members of a Govern: ment who must all take their share of blaine but I altogether refuse to accept Mr. Morley's theory that because I am jointly responsible, I am, therefore, precluded from admitting the mistakes that we made or forbidden to do justice to our successors, who have, fortun nately, avoided our errors and perhaps have taken warning by our example, Mr, Morley's doctrine goes far beyond avy limitation that statesmen have heretofore imposed on themselves; but no doubt it is calculated to satisfy the views of the party hacks who hold that the party must be supported, right or wrong.

Most. people will probably agree with the Manchester Guardian; "Phe first and last word of our Cabinet system is collective responsibility. Loyalty to one's leader and one's colleagues and inviolable secrecy as to what pastes within the Cabinet are its plain corollaries. Mr. Chamberlain seems never to have understood those honourable obligations, He tried to form a Cabinet within the Cabinet, and uow he caps everything by denouncing the policy of the Cabinet of which he was from first to last a member and for whose actions, therefore, he was himself as absolutely responsible as Mr, Gladstone."

The Pall Mall has a forcible drawing by F. C. Gould of Mr. Chamberlain as a rat-tlesuake, Ils fr ce is a very good sketch of a dog's broken leg bein bandaged at Guy's, It has some of the same vid Japanese pictures from Sir Edwin Arnold's new hook, some good sketches of the floods in the Thames Valley, a horrible full-page illustration of an ancient Briton", some pretty sketches of the lower Thames, ete., etc. As to reading matter it is a scrappy number.

The Mustrated has some more pictures of the floods in the Thames valley, wud the Chinese who see them must chuckle when they recall the tons of good advice they have had as to regulating their rivers. The Graphic has a powerful drawing by Frank Brangwyn, and a very good one after Marks," The sketch of Bishop Julius doing hoisted to the top of the spire of Christ Church Cathedral, to lay the Jast brick, shows what marvellous feats bishops are expected to perform in New Zealand. The Graphiz has a good article on " India's New Buffer":

The visit of Lord Lansdowne to the Happy Valley has a deeper significance than appears to Eoglish aninds. Ye. will. be recognised through India asa proof that the Government, anxious to block every possible approach to Hindustan from the North, has resolved to assume direct and immediate control over Cashmere. The pregnant words just uttered by the Viceroy at Srinagar will strengthen this conviction. While professing perfectly friendly feelings towards the Vaharajah, the representative of British rule spoke as one with whom it exclusively rested to mould and guide the future policy of the little State.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account