ip gave judgment in this case, as follows This isan action brought by n CI {vendor of lund against the burch er for balance of unpaid purchase mone; The evidence shows that x balance still i to tre vendor. alleges that he has paid the entire amount to the broker through whom the purchase was effected, and claims, that this should be held a camp! discharge so far us he is concerned. One fof the grounds on which he relied in i support of th ion wns the eust item of Shanghai. But of Shanghai was proved; it ary, therefore, - for met whether if such a custom had been p-rived, it would have over-ridden the Buglish law upon the subject. Tt is right that I should out that the law istered in th t is the law gland, and the of England only. There are cases in which the Inw of England says that the law of some other country or the custom of a place or business shall govern. But then the law of the country "it the custom must be proved by experts and as one of the facts of the ease.
Here no law or custom was, proved, and Tau left to deal with the case according to the law of England, The law of England undoubtedly is that the agent for the sale of land is not entitled, without special authority, to receive the purchase money.
For the purposes of this case, and as between the vendor and the defendant, it must be taken that Mr. Dzienk was the agent for the sale, The defendant himself insisted upon this, and set it up as his defence to the plaintiffs petition, The payment to Mr, Dzionk can not therefore be taken as payment te the vendor, for no special authority to Me, Dzionk tw receive the purchase money was proved, It was said by the defendant that the vendor should have seen that he got the money before the transfer of the land at the United States Consulate; but it appears by the Chinese deed that the payment was to he made on the day the conveyance was executed and the defendant explained this as meaning when he got the title deed frou the United states Consulate, Itdoes not appear in evidence that the vendor was present when this occurred, and moreover the Chinese deed stated that a separate receipt would be given for the purchasomoney, This receipt the defendant has not proved, and it nowhere appears that he obtained or asked for it, The question then becomes what amount is still due to the vendor?
The principal item: in dispute is " sum of four bundyed and eight dollars, (8408) whids was undoubtedly paid by the defendant, who says it was on account of the purchase money, The vendor says that the amount was puld partly for the expenses of the removal of the graves which were on the Innd, and partly for the land on which the graves were. Itappears thatin-he Chinese document upon which the title deed registered in the United States Consulate was obtained, the ground occupied by the graves was expressly excepted.
Tealso appears chat the defendant is now in possession of the whole of the land cluding this grave-rpace, The probability therefore is that this payment of 8403 lind some relation to the inclusion of this extra space in the title deed.
Mr. Dzionk, while stating that the vendor ought to pay this $408, also snys that Mr, Middleton ought (o pay for the graver spa Luis grave-space, it appeata from the Chinese deed, was $ fun 2 li. This at Tis, 50 per mow coman to The. 12. Ace ending to the defendant's own ease therefore Tis, 176.84 only should be credited to him out of the sum of $408; and without going into the question further, which would T think necessitate the hearing "f additions evidence, Lam inclined to credit him with this amo Making up the account upon this basic it appears that he paid—Bargain money...
Tls, 225.00 Chinese officials vs 280.00 United States Ca 64.00 Baluice of $408, after pay ment for grave spice... sy 176.84
Total... is, 695.84 leaving a balance due to the vendor of is, 1,163.16. Ae Tam not g.ving the plaintiff all that Mr. Wilkinson contended he was entitled to, I could not give judgment for this amount without hearing further evidence or obtaining Mr. Wilkinson's consent. If therefore Mr. Wilkinson cmsents I am prepared to give judgment for this aumunt and to assess the costs, Mr. Wilkinson assenting, his Lordship gave judgment for Tls. 1,163.16 with, $176, costs,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.