The Archive · 1892

DR.. MYERS ON. CHINESE SUGAR MANUFACTURE. 5

'7th April. Wuarever unsuspected accumulations of raw material nature may still have in store destined to nourish fresh haman industries, and at once to create and supply wants hitherto unfelt, the expectation of national wealth is prudently based, not on the anticipation of fortunate surprises, but on' the diligent development of resources already worked unto the knowledge of the hour. Every new mechanical device whereby the energy latent in fuel, in falling water, in the ether which surrounds and penetrates the universe of things, is first set free and then economise, augments wealth to a greater degree and on a higher plane than does, for example, each fresh discovery of subterranean reservoirs of mineral oil. 'l'o alike level of wealth-creation belong the utilization of products, such as the residues of coal-gas manufacture, wasted during many years, and the discovery of methods for the cheap production on a colossal scaleofsuchametalasaluminium, but recently a mere laboratory curiosity, now of the widest applicability to manifold arts and industries. The superiority of methods over isolated achievements corresponds to the superiority of the general over the particular, and so it comes to pass that the truest benefactor of his "species is he who really or figuratively causes two blades of grass to sprout wherever, before him, only one could be produced. In a word, the wealth arising out of any enterprise is augmented exactly in that ratio in which by altering the quality but not the quantity of the antecedents, the final result is, within the limits of possible demand, increased or rendered more desirable, Yo this order of ideas belongs a work by Dr. W. W. Myers of Takow, notice of which in these columns has been too long delayed. Taking up the sugar industry of Formosa and observing with a species of horror the wastefulness of, the methods employed to produce a very inferior article of export, Dr. Myers has set himself to advocate the employment of European machinery whereby at less ultimate expense and with less labour two pounds of good sugar can be made to replace one pound of bad. Ihis in round terms is the conclusion which in an elaborately illustrated Chinese treatise addressed to sugar manufacturers and officials, he endeavours to enforce by means of a formidable array of facts and figures drawn from foreign sources. Supposing the conclusion accepted, he supports its tactical outcome in the adoption of european methods by arguments addressed to the most potent of all personal motives—self-interest.

The work before us was composed in English, and translated into Chinese by Mr. J, R. Brazier of the Customs Service. It is.a reprint from the Ohinese Scientific and Industrial Magazine, in which widely-read periodical it appeared under and earlier months of 1891. Following astrictly logical arrangement, Dr. Myers first indicates the importance of his subject by pointing on the one hand to the wealth of raw material furnished by the Formosan sugar plantations and on the other to the inefficient, extravagant and slovenly methods of preparation actually adopted which dissipate in waste the prosperity that nature offers with open hands. A section devoted to the importance of sugar as food, that is, as fuel for the vital machine, leads to a short dissertation on the chemistry of vital functions and of organic reactions in general, illustrated by familiar but ingenious and suggestive examples taken from the events and accidents of daily life. How far all this will instruct the Chinese reader may be doubtful, but it is calculated to interest him, inasmuch as it shows that sugar being one of the necessities of the human economy, there will always be a demand for it. It further shows that inasmuch as the commercial value of a sample of sugar depends on the amount of crystalline substance it contains, whils this erystalline substance is always ready to degenerate into molasses when the mode of preparation is careless and dirty, the knowledge that such modes powerfully aid this degeneration has an enormous money value for those who choose to act on it.

Having exhausted the chemistry of sugar and of its immediate derivatives, and thoroughly explained its relation to physiological processes; having likewise shown the practical and mercantile bearing of these facts gathered from the daily experience of common life and from laboratory experiments, the various sugar-producing plants are passed in review, and a detailed description of the sugar cane is given, including its render its environment favourable to its morphology, and the conditions which

fall development or the reverse. Here again the lesson is enforced that the ultimate outcome of a crop depends for its value upon the intelligent application of accurate knowledge. Haphazard cultivation of the plant is as fatal as haphazard preparation of the raw material. The practice actually adopted in Formosa appears to be to allow the cane to grow pretty much like a weed, although, as Dr. Myers shows by elaborate discussion and explanation, indefinitely great possibilities lie in the application of scientific principles to its propagation, its manuring, its irrigation, and its protection against parasites.

'A chapter on the empirical: composition of cane-juice serves as an introduction to a detailed description of the best foreign methods of extraction and preparation. Here the reader finds the fullest practical information regarding the machinery required, the cost of purchase, transport, installation and maintenance, and calculations as to the profit both in quality and quantity to be gained by replacing the primitive contrivances ju use at present by the machinery which is found to give the best results in other sugar-growing regions. To the ordinary reader this is the most interesting part of the work, Fully to realise how sugar is manufactured in Formosa is sufficient to cause any one endowed with a vivid imagination and an unstable stomach to auure sugar as a comestible for the remainder of his natural life. Wisely however, it is not upon aesthetic considerations that Ds, Myers bases his condemnation of the filthy manner in which the juice is manipulated and the horrible impurities which are allowed to mingle with it, He is addressing Chinese readers who care for none of these things, He shows that by indiscriminately crushing all parts of the cane in the endeavour to secure mere bulk, what is commercially the most valuable element in the juice is ruined by reduction to a valueless form; further that the filth introduced

aration continues the degradation of into the juice in the peeves of its pre-the crystallisable portion of the mass and finally that the slowness of the resent methods works to the same disastrous end. It follows from an elaborate calculation that through ignor ance, greed and carelessness, no less than one-third of the income which might be derived from each crop is totally lost. Yet even this does not by any means adequately represent the difference between what is realised as money and what might be realised, For the molasses, as such, there is practically no market and therefore it is treated as mere waste. But Dr, Myers shows that it is not an unsaleable product that is thus lost, but an eminently saleable one, namely alcohol, and he proceeds to explain how alcohol may be produced on a large scale and at a minimum expense from this despised article, Tt will thus be seen that nothing, from the planting of the cane to the utilization of every element in its yield, has been neglected. Upon every comer of the processes employed, light derived from the best foreign sources -has been directed. Whether old custom and the ingrained love of the Chinese people for all that is imperfect, inaccurate and clumsy will yield before Dr. Myers' luminous arguments is we think doubtfal. But should ever the day come when the loss of a lucrative trade brings home to cultivators and manufacturers the absolute need for active and intelligent competition with better-armed rivals, Dr. Myers' monograph will necessarily be the guide and handbook of more enlightened generation.

We have barely indicated in its bolder outlines the scope of the pam-Hetails would not interest the bulk of)hlet before us. The discussion of minute

our readers, But we have done enough to show that Dr. Myers has proved himself a benefactor it posse to all who are engaged in the Formosa sugar industry, whether natives or foreigners, from the humble. peasant farmer to the European purchaser and exporter, Whether he will prove a benefactor in

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account