The Archive · 1893

Sint,—The Editor of the Hongkong Daily

Noxrn-Curya Dany News

Press, in his paper of the 18th of August, ends n friendly criticism of my letter dated. the 10th of the same month with the remark that, "to show that wages and the cost of living have remained stationary is only equivalent to showing that in the country where that is the case there his been no progress, no increase in the general well-being of the community, nothing but stagnation."

Tf the Editor will look carefully into my lotter he will tind, T think, that what he interprets as the conclusions to which my arguments lend, are in reality the premises which they were based.

T hold that, heranse there has been progress in this country, the argument of the gold monometallists,' that, the decline in the gold price of commodities is nob owing to any appreciation of that metal, but to improved methods of production and distribution, can be more readily disproved here than elsewhere.

The chief contention that T have sought to establish, in the letters T have written of gold, nnd i have ondeavourvd to prove on the subject, has been the appreciate

it by comparisons with the prices of commodities here, which have been little, if at all, affected by recent improvements in me-clinical appliances and transportation; my opinion being that, until he appreciation gold becomes generally recognised the' element of disturbance in the finance of the world, it is almost hopeless to look for any alleviation of the troubles caused thereby, and that, when this fact is fully realised, an effective remedy will speedily be found. My object, has been to throw such light on the subject. as this country affords towards the establishment of what T believe to he the truth.

T should, therefore, be going far wide of my mark, if Tallowed myself to be drawn into discussions of propositions, more or less abstract, to which the Editor of the Duily Press invites me, though he suggests some very interesting and alluring subjects for those who are controversially inclined.

There is one point, however, on which I feel called upon to join issue with him, and that is his statement that " currency arguments drawn from such a source (China) therefore require considerable correction before they can be applied to the conditions of more progressive communities."

To this I would reply that, generally speaking, the principles of political economy apply in the same way to all communities, whether progressive or stationary. So far as my own argument in connection with the horseboy's wages and cost of living is concerned, what Iattempted to prove by. this illustration was that, the purchasing power of silver, with respect to the necessaries of life, had not diminished during the Baa not declined in value compared with period referred to, which showed that

commolites, while gold had largely merous ed in its purchasing power, which proved

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account