The Archive · 1893

The Chief Justice—As to the spot

Mr. Wilkinson—And as to the features d, That he took it—and his (Mr, Lowder) did not pute it—brought the particular spot within the Japanese territorial waters as ordinarily, understood in books upon international law, but what he understood the other side to say was that the municipal law of Japan did not extend to those waters in matters relating to ships.

The Chief Justice—So as to exclude any other law; that is what I imagine the proposition to be Mr. Wilkinson remarked that proposition would be equally barren, for the reason that if the Japanese municipal law applied there, it did nob matter what atler Courts ction. What his learned friends "Inasmuch as other Courts have jurisdiction there the municipal law of Japan relating to cullisions—leaving aside ug of extraterritoriality—does to the three mile limit, tha it stops at low-water mark." They contended that' the law that applied beyond low-water mark was the general maritime law and not the law of the country, and the cases which were cited were intended to show that. Procooding to comment upon the cases cited, the learned counsel argued that the Chartered Mercantile Bank v. the Netherlands Steam Navigation Company, was a very differ ent exse from the present one, as it arose out of a collision between two steamers on a voyage from Singapore to Sourabaya and undoubtedly on the high sexs. The case did not go to the extent of the exclusive jurisdiction of the country, but his leatued friend, on account of the use of that word exclusive," founded an argument which he (Mr. Wilkinson) submitted was fallacious. Mr. Lowder had cited other

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account