The Archive · 1893

H.B.M.'s CIVIL SUMMARY COURT

Shanghai, 7th October.

Before Groxox Jawesox, Esq., Assistant Julye, CueNa Soonc-ron x. Ronerrs.

Mr, John Roberts, diver, speared to answer a summons taken out against him by Cheng Soong-foh, a diver, for $61 58, The summons stated that the money was due by defendant to plaintiff in virtue written agreement made nud entered in between the plaintiff and defendant 26th July 1392, by which defendant agreed to give plaintiff and seventeen other native divers 25 per cent, of the value of all cargo salved by him with the assistance of the divers from the wreck of the s.e. Hsinsheng. The cargo so recovered was sold for Ti 4,399.42 and the defendant had on the divers $398, of which sum plaintiff only received as his share, $22, leaving $61 58 still due by defendant to plaintiff.

Mr. W. A. C. Platt upbeared for the plaintiff, and defendant conducted his own case, Mr. Platt suid the claim arose out of the wreck ut the s.s. Hsinsheng. Mr, Roberta engaged eighteen divers, of whom the plaintiff was one, to help him in recovering the cargo, and " written agreement was entered into between the parties in which defendant xgreoi to pay the divers 25 per cent. of the net proceeds of the cargo salved from the wreck. Mr, Roberts and the divers proceeded to the wreck and salved a considerable quantity of cargo, which was st_down to Shanghai in two steamers, the Poochi and the Fungshun, 'The was gold and he would prove from the China Merchants' Company's books that the net proceeds were Tis, 4,399, and the share of the divers, turning it into dollara, would be $1,506." The divers would say that all they had been paid was $398, leaving $1,108 still due to them, The suit was originally brought in the Supreme Court, wher: however, the divers were met by'nn orde to deposit security for costs, and as they were unable to do this, the step the learned Counsel had taken was this. Under the agreement each diver was entitled to an eighteenth share of the balance still due, $1,108, wud he had advised the plaintiff who was proving the present summons, to bring a suit in the Summary Court, for his share, which was $61.58.

Defendant disclaimed owing the divers thing, for he alleged they broke their agreement xt the North-east Promontory. They agreed to go to the wreck and work until everything was finished, and as isted on leaving befure the opera-were completed, they agreed to accept $200, which defendant paid them, in full satisfaction of their claim, After paying all expenses, defendant himself, and two other foreigners who were with him, did not make " dollar out of the wreck.

The agreement between the parties having been put in 'Cheng Soong-foh, the plaintiff, was called. He said he lived at Ningpo. The first heard about saving thie cargo was from Mr. Roberts' boy, who asked him to come to 0 Make arrangements, Witness teen other came to Shanghai and signed the agreement produced, by marking line on it, As soon os thi agreement was signed Mr. Roberts gav: them $20, and $80 dollars the next August and in defiance of me and the other day. Before they went to the wreck they received another $20. In company with the defendant they went to the wreck in the steamer Fungshio, arriving on the 8th of the intercalary moon last year. They commenced work ihe next day; they worked for over a month, but they re-there two months. The salved cargo the Fungshux, Whilst they were at the wreck Roberts gave them $3 to buy food, On the way back to Shanghai they received $15. Before they left the wreck Mr. Roberts gave them an order for $200 the China Merchants' Company in nghai, and on arriving here they obed the money, leaving subsequently for Ningpo. As they had been asked by three weeks, aud'came back to Shanghai Mr. Roberts they stayed at Ningpo for

to settle accounts, They saw the defendant in Shanghai, and asked him for more money. He gave them $20, $15, $5, and $20 at various times, in all $60. About five or six days elapsed between the pay-'The defendant never told them the salved cargo had been sold for. any more money.

Mr, Platt said this was all he wished to ask the plaintiff, but he had an account of what the goods fetched.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account