In the New York "Nation" of the 18th of October is an article on the above subject. The writer evidently did not know the object of the expedition, for he says: "Por what purpose did the expeditionary force set out for Paotingfu on Thursday? For vengeance. There had taken place in that city a bloody massacre of innocent foreigners. Therefore, there must now take place there a still bloodier mas-sacro of a still greater number of innocent Chinese." It will be seen from the following facts that the object of the expeditionary force was not vengeance, but the just punishment of those officials who were really responsible for the massacre of innocent and defenceless men, women, and children. Let it be remembered too, that these men had gone with their wives and children to that place under promise of protection from the Chinese Government, whose representatives the guilty officials were. That promise was deliberately broken, And what had actually taken place at Paotingfu? Let a Chinese Christian woman who was with some of the murdered missionaries up to a short time before they were massacred tell the story. What happened after she was separated from the missionaries she learnt from tier two nephews who followed them to the exccution ground. The woman told her story to Mr. and Mrs. Green on their return to Paotingfu on the 5th of September, after they had been for about three weeks in the hands of the Boxers. Mr. Green told the story to mo, and I have the notes I took at the time before me as I write.
Let me preface the account by mentioning the different missions which had a station at this place. Outside the North Gate was the compound of the American Presbyterian Board, and living there on the 3rd of June were Dr. Taylor, Mr. and Mrs. Simcox and three children, and Dr. and Mrs. Hodge—the latter only having reached China in April of last year. Outside the South Gate was the compound of the American Board. Mr. Pitkin was in charge at the time, and at the ladies' house were Miss Gould and Miss Morrell with a number of Chinese women. Not far from them was the house of the China Inland Mission, then occupied by Mr. and Mrs. Bagnall and their five-year-old, fair-haired, dear little Gladys. "Mr. William Cooper, co-director of the China Inland Mission in China, was their guest at the time.
Though there had been much to disquiet and perplex the missionaries since the 98th of May, when the Peking-Paotingfu railway was destroyed and the station at Féngt'ai butit, the real trouble at the mission compounds only began on Saturday, the 8rd of June. The first place to be attacked was the building of the American Presbyterian Board outside the North Gate. The outbreak was sudden and unexpected, for only a short time before Dr. Taylor had been at his beneficent work in the city. The Boxers surrounded the mission premises, and on Dr. Taylor coming out to speak to the mob he was killed in the courtyard, Mr. and Mrs. Simoox and their three children, together with Dr. and Mrs. Hodge, took refuge in the upper storey of their house, which was set fire to by the rabble, and they all perished in the flames. This occurred about mid-day on Saturday. The news soon spread to the South suburb and the missionaries there were greatly grieved and alarmed and cppent most of the remainder of the day in prayer.
Quite a number of Christian Chinese women were with Miss Gould and Miss Morrell and they an said they would stand by them to the last. Most of that night was spent in prayer and there was but little sleep for any of them. By four o'clock on Sunday morning, the Ist of July, all were up and astir in the ladies' house, and one by one the women left, perhaps realising that they would be quite unable to assist their teachers, until only the Bible-woman was left, and she said she would remain and die with them. Soon after daylight the people of the South suburb, "neighbours of the missionaries, gathered and first attacked and looted all the unoccupied rooms of the American Board Mission. Having taken all they could they then went and called the Boxers who came and attacked the place in force. Mr. Pitkin was alone in one house, and being armed was able for some time to defend himself. After a time he was shot in the leg by a soldier, while others got in the back of the house and quickly overcome and killed him. His body was decapitate ed and the head bung up in a busket on a tree at tee gate of the compound. The rioters then broke into the house of the ladies, where they found Miss Gould already dead, she having been killed by the fright and strain. They took Miss Mor-tell and the Chinese Bible-woman, to-gother with Miss Gould's dead body, to a temple in the city, where they were left to be gazed upon by crowds of people. The buildings bad already been set on fire, and when Afr, Bagnall saw the smoke and flames he, with his wife and child und Mr. William Cooper, went at once to a camp near by, the officer in charge of which had for years been friendly with him. This man, Colonel Wang Chan-Kwee, at first took them in, but that same day basely handed them over to the Boxers, by whom they were taken to the temple in the city where Miss Morrell bad been lodged. Boxer placards had been previously circulated saying that the rain would not come till the foreigners were destroyed, and soon after the missionaries were taken the much-desired rain began to fall. This was at once taken as an indication that the action of the Boxers was in accord with the wishes of the gods. All that long day the little group of foreigners was kept on that temple stage exposed to the gaze of thousands. Little Gladys kept saying to her mother: "Mother, let us go away, why don't we go away?" Between five and six ye lock in the evening, while.tho rain waa still coming down in torrents, the little bands of martyrs was taken from the temple in the city to a vacant spot of ground outside the South gate, just hind a house once occupied by Mr. Bagnall, and there executed in the sight of thousands, many of whom thronged the adjoining city wall. The two nephews of the woman who related the story were standing close to the place of execution, and told her that there was some difficulty in executing Mr. Cooper as he was very stout, and that the crowds laughed and jeered at his sufferings. Dear little Gladys was left standing after her parents were dead, and as she stood there crying for her mother was suddenly thrust through with appear. One hesitates to write such details as the foregoing, but in the present state of feeling it is well that the facts should be known.
The Chinese Bible-woman who was with Miss Morrell was not killed as she was known to the Boxers and soldiers, but was handed over to the Civil authorities by whom she was kept in prison for seven weeks. Mr. and Mrs, Green and Mise Gregg reached Puotingfu on the Sth of September and soon after this woman obtained permission to see them and related the foregoing. Of most of the events she herself had been an eyewitness. Mr. and Mrs. Green never so her again, and thought that her friends must have removed her to the country. When General Gaselee arrived and heard how noyly she had stued by the foreigners he Wied every menus to and her so that sue might be rewarded, but all without success.
And what has been the punishment awarded the officials and city for such a dastardly outrage? There has been no massacre of "innocent Chinese" as was feared by the writer in the "Nation." The Rev. J. W: Lowrie, who accompanied the expedition as interpreter, writing from Paotingfu on the 16th of November said: "The execution was an imposing affair, but the Chinese were too frightened to be present and few, if any, witnessed it. The reasons for it have been published in proclamations and all the people mads aware of them. The city is terrified by the presence of foreign soldiers but too proud to really seem humbled with the punishment, severe as it is—threo chief officers beheaded, one degraded, several temples blown up, city towers the same, and the city fined 100,000 taels (ounces of silver)."
Besides the missionaries massacred many native Christians lost their lives and much of their property was destroyed. The punishment meted out to the guilty parties cannot surely be regarded as vengeance, but simply as a wise and just step towards the settlement of the present difficulties. The people follow their rulers, and it is believed by many who mow China best, that if all the officials guilty of the recent outrages could be punished, the country would soon be open again both to the missionary and trader. H. Epwarps.
Tientsin, 15th December.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.