19th April.
Sir CraupE Macpoxatp, British Minister at Tokio, has done a very praiseworthy if somewhat unconventional act in sending to the "Kobe Chronicle" of the 18th instant, a letter of considerable length dealing with che following charge made by a correspondent of the "Manila Times:" "It is a matter of history that having carefully sacked every corner of the districts occupied by the British, the soldiers were made to turn in their loot, which was stored in a large godown in the Imperial Carriage Park," ete. The home papers, as everyone knows, have been filled with reprobation of the looting in which every foreigner who had the chance is supposed to have indulged in Peking after the siege, and intelligent and observant men who' have come down from Peking have freely declared that these charges are under rather than overstatements. We are glad, therefore, to see Sir Claude Macdonald making public a very strong contradiction of the accusations of wanton, cruel, and indiscriminate looting, based on his own observation during the period when this form of robbery was supposed to be at its height, that is, from the 14th of August until the 25th of October last year. Sir Claude points out that during that period he was constantly walling or riding through the districts placed under British control; that within a fortnight of the troops entering Peking these districts were in excellent order, no Chinese who had remained in their houses being ejected or molested; that these Chinese were deeply grateful to the military police for the protection given them, and loaded Captain Barrow with testimonials and presentation umbrellas: and that in the Chinese city the markets were held as if there had never been any siege, and the banks and pawnshops were soon re-opened. The loot that was brought to the British Legation for sale came from the houses of wealthy mandarins and high officials who had taken the Boxer side and had fled or been killed. " The empty houses and palaces," says Sir Claude, "were converted into quarters and a military hospital for the troops, who would otherwise have had to bivouac in the streets of the dirtiest city in the world. I have since heard that a great part of the Prize Fund has been expended in buying rice for the starving poor in Peking during the winter months." Sir Claude then defends General Gaselee from a charge which even the man who made it must have known to have been false, and winds up by saying that of course he speaks only for the part of Peking under English control.
To this we may properly add the following facts and figures received from our Peking correspondent What is not generally known is that the Boxers did most of the looting. Two months before the Allies entered the city the "Harmonious Fists" had organised their reign of terror. From the time the Empress decided to use these outlaws as the "tools of tumult" they began their programme of massacre, destruction, and loot. The houses that are destroyed were destroyed by them and apart from Trea-sunes, palaces, godowns and gratianos, such parts of the city as have been sacked were sacked' by these ruffians. The Chinese strongly affirm that during the months of the siege and immediately after the f of the Legations, their own soldiery and not the foreign troops raided the shops, plundered the houses, and pillaged the place. The ruins at the Chienmén, on Legation Street, and on the Shunchihmén Road are witnesses of their fury and destruction, aggression and vandalism.
Another fact is this: from the first, so far as the British and American Forces are concerned, looting was distinctly prohibited. The very first of the Standing Orders issued to the China Force was this:—"The strictest discipline will be maintained in the force, and men are warned that any looting or ill-treatment of the inhabitants will be severely punished.
Ill-treatment of transport coolies will be severely punished." And again the Field Force Orders: " Nothing is to be burned, destroyed, or looted without orders." After the relief' of the Legations General Gaselee so far modified these orders as to cancel punishment and countenance the systematic collection of articles found in abandoned houses that had to be searched for purposes of military occupation and police. Such articles were confiscated and put into a common fund for the benefit of the whole force. The search parties were detailed by Major-General Sir N. R. Stewart, and were always under the command of a British officer. he articles were handed over to the common fund. It is quite true that the Government treasure, silk godowns, and granaries were seized by the Allies and some miscellaneous pilfering was secretly carried out, but it is not the case that there was "lawless looting and wanton destruction of property." The total amount realised, from the articles handed in by search parties and publicly confiscated was as follows Treasure (Government)...$140,000 Silk 130,000 Sundries 60,000 per share. There are facts in these figures which show that the principles of the Standing Orders were the practice of the force.
It is further the testimony of the Chinese that so far from having been treated barbarously, as they expected, they have enjoyed more liberty, justice, and peace than they would have done in ordinary times under their own Government. "These foreigners are not barbarians after all," said a, leading Tartar the other day, " why, they have not burned the city and massacred the people as we ourselves would have done in similar circumstances, If we had captured the Legations do you think we would have allowed any one to remain alive or left one stone upon another? More people were killed by our own troops in making a passage through the N.W, Gate for the escape of the Empress Dowager than suffered death at the handset the allied troops. These foreigners are lenient, we are heart less, The cortaye of the Empress trampled on the mangled corpses of those slain to let her pass. These foreigners have captured our capital and occupied it without atrocity or revenge. Icall that wonderful." Yes, the Chinese, of Peking at least, will be sorry when the evacuation takes place. Some three hundred thousand dollars have been spent in Engineering, Railway, and Commissariat services by the British troops alone. The circulation of so much money and the honesty in handling it are material benefits quickly recognised and fully appreciated.
Seeing we are not at war with China, and further since the Allies all signed the Hague Conference articles on the " Rules and Usages of War," the following must be classed as unjustifiable actions 1. The atrocities committed by Russian troops.
2. The punitive expeditions ganized by various Powers. 3. The armed support given to adjust the claims of Catholic Christians by the French authorities or at all events by French troops. 4. The looting of the Peking Observatory, 5. The charity from loot practised by some American and British Yet there has not been a "groaning country" bleeding at every vein "when murders, rapes, and massacres prevailed," as might be supposed from the articles that are appearing in the magazines. But war is now as ever the son of Hell:—
"When angry heavens do make their minister Throw in the frozen bosoms of our art Hot coals of vengeance."
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.