The Archive · 1899

Mr. Wilkinson—Yes

His Lordship—Now, as you said before, it is distinctly the law of England that, under the circumstances, we must look at to give evidence of and to consider the law of the country of domicile. Now is there auy'means of getting at the luw of a foreign country—and T think for the purposes of this suit and this Court we must consider Canada in the same light as a foreign country? Is there any means of getting at what is the law of that country except in the ordinary way in which evidence of the Inw of a foreign country ix given, namely, by calling somebody to jyroduce a book who could say that it properly and correctly states what is the law? I cannot allow such a proceeding as the mere production of a printed document.

Mr. Wilkinson said the document he wished to put in was one officially printed at Ottawa by the Queen's printers. 3 His Lordship said that such " document by itself would not be accepted in an English court as proving foreign law.

Mr. McNeill said he wished to formally object to the document being allowed to His Lordship said that if Mr. Wilkinson had a Canadian Inwyer present, and were cross-examined, the defendants might be able to upset his (Mr. Wilkinson) contention altogether.

Mr. Wilkinson asked his Lordship to take a note that he offered the document as printed by the Queen's printers at Ottawa. It was cited as the Insurance Act of Canada cap. 124, 1886 ns_amended by 51 Viet.. cap. 28 (1888), 57 Vict., cap. 20 (1894), 58 and 59 Viet., exp. 20 (1895), and 62 wid 63 Viet exp, 13 (1800).

Mr. McNeill pointed out that the document Mr. Wilkinson sought to put in was an appendix to the report of the Superintendent of Insurance of Candia, Mr. Wilkinson, asked the. ground" of Mr. MeNeill's objection.

Mr. MeNeill said his Lordship had already anticipated it—that foreign law was to be proved by a person famille with the law.

Mr. Wilkinson, quoting very larvely from reported cases, argued that an interiny receipt was one of the wagering contracts. left valid by the act of George III, 13, cap 48, as to insurance on lives. He was drawing attention to the company's pro-pectus and contending that it was there stated that policies were issued absolutely unconditionally, when His Lordship pointed out that the meaning was that the person assured was untrammelled in his actions after the policy had been issued. The question in the present case was what Mr. Joly did before he got the interim receipt.

Me. Wilkinson, continuing his armament, said his contention was thnt the contract was a preliminary insurance, It was a wagering contract whereby, in c"nsideration of a certain sum, the life of the applicant was assured pending the consideration by the insurers as to whether they would issue the thing applied for—a policy. The applicant was absolutely insured for a fixed time mentioned in the receipt, or until notice of rejection ven, The applicant was insured whilst the insurers were able to enquire whether the statements made by the applicant were true, and if true, whether policy such as applied for should be issued. The learned counsel went un to: remark that even so far back as 1896 the: defendant company bad in its possession the information that Mr. Joly's life had been refused, upon which it based its action in 1898.

His Lordship said this information was contained in the card index founded upon the information furnished by the Rejection Exchange, and it was quite unreasonable to imagine that until the company received Mr. Joly's application and turned up his name that the information could be in the hands of its managers, or be of use. Tt would be quite impossible, also, for the company to communicate to its ayonts the information it held of every objection.

Me. Wilkinson quoted a case in which the contention of the defendants was a similar one—that the facts of the case were not properly disclosed. Tt had reference tw a fort in the West Indies—Fort Marlborough—the Governor of which insured it with underwriters against eapture, The fort was attacked and taken, but the underwriters contested the claim because the Governor did not. tell them how many guns there were, that it was rather " commercial trading fort than a military one, and that if a really large expedition came up the river it would surely fall into the enemy's hands, The

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account